Microsoft might still be a contender in this game -- they spent some $5B and managed to attain that position in gaming despite a very late start (compared to Sony and Nintendo). Though you should remember Sony were resting on their PS2 laurels, and Nintendo were licking their wounds at the time. Both Apple and Google are still with a cut-throat we-have-to-win-this attitude, and they are strong opponents.
The HTC Dream was an odd little device, but it still holds a special place in my heart (I ended up buying one dirt cheap to hack on, so I could use my N1 for daily use)
I wouldn't just point to Android's immaturity. The G1 is just not a great design. Perhaps, if Dalvik could make use of the Jazelle extensions or the presentation layer made use of the GPU, the G1 would present a better experience, but, overall, I wouldn't expect it to fly.
Shortly thereafter, I bought a Nexus One.