Re:Pianoplayer: Automatic fingering generator for piano scores
by holri on Sunday October 31, 2021 @03:22PM
(#29059565)
Yes I know this rule: no thumb on black keys. My teacher says it is dumb, and I agree. It depends on the musical context. Thumb on black key can be a disaster or a brilliant solution. There a no rules and a lot of factors to consider. Good fingering is very subjective and depends foremost on musical understanding of the desired emotional outcome.
I do not understand what statistics or machine learning can add here.
Re:Pianoplayer: Automatic fingering generator for piano scores
by tofflos on Sunday October 31, 2021 @01:16PM
(#29058522)
> Just as an example, one of the first things I learned from my Russian master teacher was to never put the thumbs on the black keys.
Ugh. I'm hard pressed to even reach an octave using only pinky and index. You probably have bigger hands.
Just as an example, one of the first things I learned from my Russian master teacher was to never put the thumbs on the black keys.
That's _unless_ it's absolutely neccessary to do so in some of the more advanced fingerings. It also all depends on how large your hands are.
So there's really no one-size-fits-all solution, but I could imagine a transformer architecture trained on master fingerings might actually be able to figure it out.