That sounds a bit exaggerated. There is evidence that occupational exposure to PVC compounds causes liver damage or cancer, and that’s mostly regarding workers in production lines. You’d have to be closely sniffing your record collection for hours on end to get the same effect.
If this was true you’d have entire generations from the 19x0s suffering from liver failure, as vinyl was the only media available, with billions of records sold.
> Livers from rats provided with diet containing 2% DEHP show an increased number of peroxisomes after a few days
> In spite of the lack of direct evidences […] the indications so far obtained are sufficiently unequivocal not to be neglected
> We have reasons to believe that accumulating toxicity is valid for humans
> which means that evaluation of chronic human toxicity cannot be performed until around 2000 to 2020!
From that to “vinyl records will damage your liver” seems like a huge jump.