News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by colechristensen on Friday October 29, 2021 @06:31PM (#29044270)
This is a problem all over, from health advice to cooking to skincare, lawn care, etc. etc. etc.

A complex system with many variables and optimum points trying to be solved with anecdotes, magical cures, and "good for you" products.

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by Larrikin on Friday October 29, 2021 @06:42PM (#29044350)
Atleast with cooking I've collected a few sources that are consistently good. For new recipes I follow them exactly the first time and disregard any source that has had more than a couple not great recipes, specifically any recipe on all recipes that not a sponsored professional chef.
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by colechristensen on Friday October 29, 2021 @07:01PM (#29044495)
(for cooking, but also others) There usually are good sources and they fall under two categories (or both): very precise procedure which was actually tested or technique and feedback focused information. The latter being far more important. How to adjust, signs to look for (sound, smell, taste, sight), the proper uses of tools, etc.

"This is how I do it!" blog kinds of recipes usually suffer from hidden techniques or undocumented variables where you try it yourself and it's just awful.

In other words, good advice involves science and art, not just one-off reports of success.

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by jamincan on Saturday October 30, 2021 @06:41AM (#29047701)
The problem, of course, is that advice focusing on technique and feedback is a lot harder to pass on, and a lot harder to absorb. It's the difference between a 30 second tik tok clip and a one hour in-depth on par-baking pie crusts.
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by quietbritishjim on Saturday October 30, 2021 @03:31AM (#29046805)
The parent comment's point is not that there is no good cooking advice out there, but instead that there are enough variables that it can't be taken at face value.

I've used a recipe that have worked very well for me but then gave radically different results when I used a different casserole dish. I managed to fix it by taking the lid off later in the process and adjusting the oven temperature by 30°C. Not many recipes mention that amount of temperature variation depending on what cooking equipment you're using.

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by tompazourek on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:46AM (#29048351)
When cooking, we often optimize for flavor and texture. But what about digestion and nutrition and how each person has different preferences and a different body? It starts getting very complicated quite fast, so many variables...
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by mabub24 on Friday October 29, 2021 @07:59PM (#29044831)
For a lot of these things, the steps to finding something that works should start with seeing someone who is a specialist of some sort, and, if at all possible, getting them to actually look at whatever you need help for.

For skincare, see a dermatologist. Anyone with skincare issues or concerns, PLEASE just see a dermatologist. They might not tell you what you want to hear, but they can usually give you a good baseline description and diagnosis of what to work on. That's 99% of the battle.

For lawn care, try to talk to a lawn care specialist, hopefully someone who is not trying to sell you something. Golf courses usually have 1 or 2 people that know a lot about grass. Even someone that you think has a really good lawn, ask them to come over and take a look at yours.

Getting advice off the internet is helpful, but I've usually found it to not beat getting someone in person who can actually look at what ever the thing is you're looking for advice for.

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by colechristensen on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:27PM (#29045745)
I have had a hard time getting any doctor to take a complex issue seriously.

If it can't be "solved" with the standard antidepressant, antibiotic, skin cream, or "diet and exercise"; good luck getting anybody to even try to solve an issue that isn't obvious. (your leg is broken, you have a tumor, etc.)

Medical expertise has a problem with only doing one dimensional solutions for one dimensional issues.

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by throaway46546 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:55AM (#29046088)
I have had similar experiences. I end up having to do my own research if I want a problem actually solved.

Another thing that bothers me is that they never seem to do any sort of testing. They just throw solutions at the problem until one of them works. It is 2021 we have had the technology to grow something in a culture for over 160 years now, but no just take these antibiotics and if they don't work come back and I'll take another random shot in the dark.

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by selfsimilar on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:39AM (#29048654)
While nominally true for many bacteria, there’s still overwhelmingly many we can’t culture, and those we can take many different media to cultivate.

“Bacterial culture is frequently more difficult and often requires more training than molecular techniques”[1]

There’s a good chance that many doctors are stuck in a mindset that culturing is too difficult, costly, and time consuming to be effective for all but the most resistant infections, but I’m not sure they’re wrong.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4284306/

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by thaumasiotes on Saturday October 30, 2021 @05:09AM (#29047259)
That matches my experience. If you see a doctor, they'll try doing whatever their flowchart says to do, and if it doesn't work, they tell you to go away. You'd get results at least as good from just looking at the flowchart yourself.

I did see a dermatologist when the skin on one of my fingertips started peeling uncontrollably. He told me 'We call this "desquamation", which just means "it's peeling". We don't know why it happens or what might make it stop.'

It was a less than ringing endorsement of the idea that if you have a skin problem, you should see a dermatologist.

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by MichaelZuo on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:53AM (#29049230)
Couldn’t you go to a medical library and look up ‘desquamation’?
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by thaumasiotes on Saturday October 30, 2021 @06:26PM (#29052771)
Yes, and it will say "we don't know why it happens or what might make it stop".
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by MichaelZuo on Sunday October 31, 2021 @08:11PM (#29061759)
You’ve already done so? Can you point to which texts say that?
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by lobocinza on Saturday October 30, 2021 @01:31AM (#29046226)
I think that apply to most professions/professionals unfortunately.
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by aspaceman on Friday October 29, 2021 @08:26PM (#29044973)
This is funny because when I saw a dermatologist they just prescribed retinol cream (the textbook solution), didn't look at my skin, and didn't much care for my thoughts or concerns about how to better care for it.

"Just take the cream damnit" - a couple years later I found that the cream was just adjusting the texture of my skin, and likely overly sensitizing it. The doc didn't care and was happy to continue prescribing it.

When doctors abscond their responsibility to know what they're talking about, folks have no choice but to seek it out. Many people have this experience with physicians of all stripes.

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by leesalminen on Friday October 29, 2021 @08:52PM (#29045072)
I just had a doctor completely mis-prescribe Azithromycin to me. They prescribed 5x the correct dose. I even asked them three times about it before leaving the appointment and they looked at me like I was crazy. Luckily my parents worked for Pfizer for a combined 80 years and confirmed my suspicions before I started taking it.
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by istorical on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:09AM (#29045907)
I had doctors give teenage me antibiotics for acne. Later on prednisone I believe. Jesus christ dermatologists are fucking awful. Never told me I needed to start washing my towels, bedsheets, pillowcases more often or suggested using a moisturizer.
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by VRay on Saturday October 30, 2021 @02:20AM (#29046468)
Haha, yeah, doctors are pretty terrible. I had neck and jaw pain, and my Chinese-born dentist said “Well, I know how much you Americans like drugs and surgery, and there are some of those that will help, but really you’ll probably be fine if you just get neck and shoulder massages occasionally”

Sure enough, it worked. I was just hurting my neck by using my PDA too much with my neck craned downward, and getting massages/exercise or just not using a mobile device fixed the problem completely

I really lucked out with that guy

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by thaumasiotes on Saturday October 30, 2021 @05:13AM (#29047272)
> I had neck and jaw pain, and my Chinese-born dentist said “Well, I know how much you Americans like drugs and surgery, and there are some of those that will help, but really you’ll probably be fine if you just get neck and shoulder massages occasionally”

To be totally fair, I did recently seek help for recurring pain in the back of my head (also the top of the neck, but I described it as the head) and the urgent care nurse did some simple nerve damage tests, asked me about my sleeping posture, and told me the problem was likely that I was sleeping wrong and I should take a different position. He was right.

Of course, he wasn't a doctor either. :/

If you want to turn the tables on your Chinese-born dentist, ask him about the Chinese habit of stopping by the hospital for intravenous saline solution whenever you're feeling like you might have a cold.

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by aidenn0 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:01AM (#29045874)
I had hallucinations and a manic episode due to a doctor prescribing the wrong amount of Adderall.
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by SkittyDog on Saturday October 30, 2021 @03:06AM (#29046686)
While terrifying, some kids would also recognize that as a terrific financial windfall if you're crooked enough to sell the excess.
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by ericbarrett on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:42PM (#29045556)
I had this happen too, with a topical steroid. Went to another dermo a few years later and they gasped out loud when I showed them my old prescription. Overdose of topical steroids can cause permanent damage to the skin.
Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by Broken_Hippo on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:00AM (#29048432)
For skincare, see a dermatologist. Anyone with skincare issues or concerns, PLEASE just see a dermatologist. They might not tell you what you want to hear, but they can usually give you a good baseline description and diagnosis of what to work on. That's 99% of the battle.

Realistically, this isn't good advice - you probably just want to see your regular doctor. The waiting list for a dermatologist can be long, but that GP will probably get you in quickly. They will recognize worrysome skin patches that might be cancer, and can generally do basic things to help common skin conditions (athletes foot, cysts, poison ivy and other common rashes, and so on).

Besides, a lot of folks can't just see a dermatologist - not without a referral, anyway.

Re:Why is houseplant advice so bad? by eru on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:35PM (#29045782)
A good place to study human confirmation bias.