This is bogus, because it ignores Observer Selection. We are not at a randomly chosen planet in the universe (or in a larger multiverse), we are at a planet where there exists observers who could observe life exists. The more uncommon observers are, the more biased our position would be.
Ask yourself: if OoL were exponentially unlikely, requiring super-astronomical numbers of tries to get it to occur, far beyond the number of stars (or even atoms) in our visible universe, what exactly would we see that's different from what we do see? If there is no such thing, how could current evidence rule out that possibility?
I will totally agree that the mechanism by which life arose should be among the easiest routes to life. But this doesn't mean that process was likely in any absolute sense, just that it was among the least unlikely.
But no matter what that probability is, when there are 2 alternative pathways for a step, we should assume the more likely one. I merely claim that
inorganics -> small replicators -> large replicators
is more likely than inorganics -> large replicatorsIs it really just pure agnostic nihilism along the lines of "We know nothing!"? Or do you know of more reasonable alternative explanations, not investigated in experiments like this?
You seem to be suggesting that a bogus conclusion is better than admitting we don't yet know. This is dishonest and I reject it.
Put another way: the most likely ancestor of all replicators was probably close to the smallest molecule that works.