In the modern era where us news is ranking schools based on graduation rates it may be more fair to say that they were a successful looking junior in high school.
https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/articles/how-...
It used to be that having graduated from a selective school was a proxy for SAT, which was a proxy for IQ, and large companies legal departments tend to refuse to sign off on IQ tests as they are possibly biased against protected classes, so recruiting from selective schools was a way to launder recruiting people with high IQ scores.
If you want to hire 100 people then using "Got into Stanford and didn't flunk out" is a fairly cheap filter to approximate these things.