News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thank goodness we don't have downmods on HN by stcredzero on Friday August 29, 2008 @02:09PM (#290258)
I am certain that it happened on reddit. In fact, there were occasions where the conspirators would go to the list of your past submissions and give you a little extra punishment to further discourage you from posting. I only had a few submissions at the time, and they were months old, so I am certain that this is what happened.

Apparently a lot of this has been addressed on reddit with some clever code. I think it's far cleverer to just leave the feature out!

Re:Thank goodness we don't have downmods on HN by raganwald on Friday August 29, 2008 @02:15PM (#290265)
I stopped using reddit after several such incidents with my raganwald account. After disagreeing with certain users there, suddenly all of my comments and posts would get downmodded in my history.

At first this would cause a karma hit, so I tried a workaround: after my submissions peaked, I would delete them and this would present a smaller surface area for revenge attacks.

This turned out to be a bad idea because it deprived reddit of the history. So I switched to a new tactic: I simply stopped participating in the forums and started submitting things under a nom de plume.

I think that they have changed things so that revenge downmods do not affect karma, but it doesn't matter to me. I stopped one day and asked myself why I was bothering to worry about my reddit karma?

Then I asked why I was bothering with reddit?

Then I closed up the nom de plume and HN is the only such site I visit. And let me tell you, I am a far, far happier man for it :-)

Re:Thank goodness we don't have downmods on HN by jcl on Friday August 29, 2008 @02:40PM (#290305)
I note that HN also discourages historic downmods. I can't downmod any posts older than a day (but I can upmod them).
Re:Thank goodness we don't have downmods on HN by stcredzero on Saturday August 30, 2008 @06:31AM (#290798)
Yup, I only visit reddit now to see what the masses are up to.