Yeah, I guess the biggest issue is someone plugging in [email protected] just to test the subscription form, and then actual John getting a maillist message and tagging it as a spam. The question here is if the same John would or would not tag a plain confirmation message as spam too, and I suspect that he would, in which case what I wrote above is no worse than a double-opt-in in edge cases.
Re:Please confirm your email address
by cookiecaper on Friday August 19, 2011 @10:39AM
(#2903498)
Except that you continue to waste the resources of both acmecorp and yourself by sending mail that no one ever sees.
1) Enter email on web page.
2) Open confirmation link in email inbox.
If you skip second step - there is a risk that email ends up in spam folder and is constantly delivered there. Another risk - user did not really request your subscription. That would often result in your emails being marked as spam.