I'd love to see a new design with network transparency in the current internet age on the foreground.
I remember working in a room with 20 big-screened X terminals connected to one server over one shared 10 Mbit 10Base-T. And it worked amazingly well.
This was when Windows was in its infancy. I'd love to see that kind of vision again.
Nowadays with modern video compressing protocols also sending the video like RDP doesn't require a lot of bandwidth either and has an acceptable latency to be fair, but with X it would be even better (and it is, if you ever used X over ssh it works great)
This is true of RDP also. The initial versions of RDP were basically GDI over the wire. Of course it's been expanded since then to include DirectX calls, etc.
> The load on the network is lower.
That is incorrect. RDP is actually usable over an internet link; X11 is far too chatty and ridden with roundtrip latency for that use case. Even VNC does better over the wire than X.
> That is incorrect. RDP is actually usable over an internet link; X11 is far too chatty and ridden with roundtrip latency for that use case. Even VNC does better over the wire than X.
Yes I use it over an internet link and it works reliably.
But the main difference between RDP and X11 forwarding is that RDP forwards the entire session, while with X11 you forward the single application. With X11 forwarding you can indeed run on the same X server different X clients. That can be an advantage in an era of microservices, because you can see an X client as a microservice, and thus have a workstation (a X server) run a plentful of X clients each one on a different machine/VM/container.
My impression is that latencies kill X performance. Having a server under my desk is one thing, but running even something like xedit halfway across a world is painful. It may be possible to update these tools to be less synchronous, but I’m not sure this is a great use case, certainly not for new applications.
> No need for HDMI or other display interfaces, just run a network cable to each monitor, plug keyboard and mouse on the monitor, you are done.
This would be great. Every monitor has at least a frame buffer and there is no need to push every pixel to the monitor 60 times a second. Worst case scenario is you have a sporting event where you need to push every pixel to the screen 60 or more times per second, but, most of the time, there’s no such need.