News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Xorg-Server 21.1.0 by bitwize on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:39PM (#29019921)
The people who write and maintain X decided that life is too short to write or maintain X. Wayland is their way forward.

Web browsers (and Electron) are replacements for NeWS, not X really. That's part of the reason why Electron won't go away, the architecture advantages are too great: have the server push running code to the local display to take advantage of local acceleration. NeWS was awesome in its day, and it kind of lives on in the form of browsers and Electron.

Re:Xorg-Server 21.1.0 by alerighi on Thursday October 28, 2021 @03:54PM (#29030973)
But they are still maintaining it. Also, the improvements that Wayland brings are not really specific to them, because they are mostly due to a new Linux kernel feature that is KMS, and you can use libinput also with X.

I don't really see the point of Wayland, to me X was just fine, sure, maybe it was time for X12, but was a completely new display server needed?

Re:Xorg-Server 21.1.0 by bitwize on Thursday October 28, 2021 @05:03PM (#29031971)
> But they are still maintaining it.

Only just barely. And they told us it could stop at any time. All the developer energy and support is behind Wayland, so that's what you should be using.

> I don't really see the point of Wayland, to me X was just fine, sure, maybe it was time for X12, but was a completely new display server needed?

The developers closest to the graphics stack say yes, so I defer to their expertise.

Really, this has been discussed to death many, many times. The arguments for X (or an X-like architecture) invariably come from people who are ignorant of the actual issues involved. Here's a video by Daniel Stone that addresses the main points; note that it was made 8 years ago and people are still arguing the points: https://youtu.be/RIctzAQOe44

As far as the graphics stack maintainers are concerned the debate is pretty much over, and Wayland won. X will get little to no developer attention going forward. Unless you want to take responsibility for the X server, your choices are to get with the program and get on Wayland, or find your use case completely unsupported.

(Note that when it comes to large projects like Xorg, corporate sponsorship is critical. The corporations are putting their money behind Wayland, not X.)

Re:Xorg-Server 21.1.0 by rbanffy on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:53PM (#29020041)
And none of the original NeWS developers miss writing apps in PostScript.