Re:Too many new papers may mean novel ideas rarely rack up c...
by carbocation on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:02PM
(#29019083)
It's painful because (IMHO) the H index is just a much worse approximation of something that we could actually achieve with PageRank for academic citations. In that case, a bunch of middling papers would be rewarded, but so too would one critical paper that lays a foundation for a field.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Too many new papers may mean novel ideas rarely rack up c...
by prionassembly on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:13PM
(#29019751)
Wouldn't betwenness centrality be better?
Think of an army randomly moving through your citation graph; the more particularly nodes are trampled over, the more pagerank it has.
Now: if this army is informed about the shortest routes and instead moves about optimally, the most-trampled over places have higher betweenness centrality. I'd like my simulated citing scientist to be smart.
Re:Too many new papers may mean novel ideas rarely rack up c...
by carbocation on Thursday October 28, 2021 @04:49AM
(#29023847)
I've tried applying PageRank to pubmed with reasonable results, but betweenness does sound compelling. Thanks!
Re:Too many new papers may mean novel ideas rarely rack up c...
by prionassembly on Thursday October 28, 2021 @09:23AM
(#29025805)
I'll give you a bonus: the Louvain algorithm for community detection. Whatever ships with Networkx, Gephi, etc. doesn't work for my (correlation-derived, pruned with graphical lasso) networks, but the Louvain method (a greedy approximation to modularity maximization; the real math magic is in the concept of modularity and the configuration model) is awesome.
Re:Too many new papers may mean novel ideas rarely rack up c...
by carbocation on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:15PM
(#29028473)
Interesting. We use Louvain for single nucleus sequencing cell type identification. Cool to think about its other applications. Thanks for sharing.
Re:Too many new papers may mean novel ideas rarely rack up c...
by lrem on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:41PM
(#29019482)
I always thought that PageRank was inspired on methods previously used for scoring academic papers. Now I'm wondering if I misunderstood something, or my professor misunderstood it first. Damn.
Re:Too many new papers may mean novel ideas rarely rack up c...
by generationP on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @10:09PM
(#29021513)
PageRank has nothing to do with h-index to my knowledge. The problem with using PageRank-like methods for academic papers is that academic papers mostly reference backwards in time (except for the occasional draft or work-in-progress being referenced, but proper cycles are rare). A triangular matrix doesn't yield an interesting stationary distribution...
Re:Too many new papers may mean novel ideas rarely rack up c...
by fooofw on Thursday October 28, 2021 @03:16AM
(#29023322)
I don't know if it makes any difference, but if PageRank should replace the h-index, the most direct equivalent would be to rank the authors rather than the papers, no?
Re:Too many new papers may mean novel ideas rarely rack up c...
by andyferris on Thursday October 28, 2021 @12:09AM
(#29022271)
You could just make it bidirectional (add the transpose and make it symmetric), right?
Re:Too many new papers may mean novel ideas rarely rack up c...
by generationP on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:52AM
(#29022835)
Too easy to game by citing the most reputed sources. Reputation shouldn't flow up a citation.