Re:After a year of ‘rampant’ cheating, elite bridge tries to...
by DSMan195276 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:24PM
(#29017869)
That seems more like a complaint about the game itself, it can't really be cheating if there's no rule against it nor anybody hiding it. It was also part of the game to try an influence when the adjournment will happen to give yourself a more favorable position to analyze (and also determine who has to seal the last move).
FWIW adjournment never really happens anymore, largely because computers just make the analysis too easy and time controls are shorter. And I do agree that it does ruin a certain aspect of the game, but I don't think that makes it cheating, it was just a different time.
Re:After a year of ‘rampant’ cheating, elite bridge tries to...
by mcguire on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:45PM
(#29018174)
Once upon a time in a Diplomacy tournament, two players locked a third into a bathroom, forcing the third player to miss a turn. The referee ruled that was acceptable, although I think later tournaments forbid that sort of thing.
Re:After a year of ‘rampant’ cheating, elite bridge tries to...
by LanceH on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @04:42PM
(#29018837)
Locking someone in a bathroom is false imprisonment and not really a clever way of playing the game. If this were a tournament it would be easy enough to get the referee's ruling reversed by threatening arrest of the players guilty of doing it. This, of course, would be blackmail and also illegal -- but much more in the spirit of the game.
Re:After a year of ‘rampant’ cheating, elite bridge tries to...
by DSMan195276 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:59PM
(#29019628)
I kinda get your analogy (assuming you were trying to make one), but I think that example is fundamentally different. With adjournment everybody already knew how it worked before the game even started, there was no surprise "technically not against the rules" kind of thing.
Re:After a year of ‘rampant’ cheating, elite bridge tries to...
by yyyk on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:03PM
(#29019675)
>I consider it cheating to recess for the day, then have your team game out all the alternatives for you.
Adjournments used to be an accepted standard of high-level match play. If both sides agreed to a rule, are aware of it, and if the rule wasn't set up so one side has an inherent advantage, is it cheating?
Re:After a year of ‘rampant’ cheating, elite bridge tries to...
by brianwawok on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:55PM
(#29017510)
Right, you would need to finish a high level game in a single day to prevent that scenario.
I consider it cheating to recess for the day, then have your team game out all the alternatives for you. It's supposed to be you against your opponent, period.
I don't think bridge would really work if you allowed open communication. I take it you've never played?