News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Dune” (The Movie), Annotated by atoav on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:09AM (#29012821)
I am glad that the movie didn't do that, I liked it precisely for the reason that it made me the fly on the wall of a greater story. I know we are used to get likeable protagonists, but ultimately I often perceive these as cheap tricks that take away from my feeling of immersion for a place. Because all the usual plotpoints and hyperfunctionalized narratives ultimately tend to turn the world they take place in into exchangable backdrops, which is the polar opposite of the idea of the Dune series, where a Place (Arakis) influences the lifes of whole societies in interesting ways. I am glad that Villeneuve managed to do without the classical Hollywood-Three-Act-Script-Consultant-Techniques that make so much of todays movie production bland and unwatchable (for people like me), precisely for the same reason: I can't care for stories where I feel the cheap tricks that make it up at every corner.
Re:“Dune” (The Movie), Annotated by gjulianm on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @10:03AM (#29013399)
But there are cheap tricks here too. The trademark Zimmer wall of sound to make a scene "impressing", the wide long shots of CGI sceneries where no one lives, the dark/cloudy environments to avoid showing more detail...
Re:“Dune” (The Movie), Annotated by atoav on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @11:23AM (#29014528)
As bot a VFX artist and a musician I can assure you that neither of those tricks were cheap : )
Re:“Dune” (The Movie), Annotated by skohan on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:57AM (#29013344)
Yeah I think you could have gotten very far with a light touch here. For instance, just a few well-placed character moments between Paul and his father would have heightened the impact of what happens later in the film. And maybe also a few scenes where the characters are actually experiencing joy together to better contrast the hardships later on. The tone of the movie is generally so dour and one-note - maybe that is part of the aesthetic Villeneuve is trying to create, but I think even a little bit of emotional range could have gone a long way.