News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by citizenpaul on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:13AM (#29010402)
Why "finally?" Was thre some petition? Has he been claiming he would for a long time?
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by andyjohnson0 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @04:43AM (#29010852)
"We've arranged to meet here to talk about his latest novel, number 17 over nearly four decades of wildly popular, cinder-block-sized sci-fi thrillers."

Because climate change is a major, global, and increasingly visible threat to our presence on this planet - and Stephenson hadn't made it a theme of any of his books over the last four decades. In the opinion of the article's author, this is significant. Seems reasonable to me.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by jeegsy on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:02AM (#29012073)
Of the top of my head, I don't recall any other issue that the zeitgeist even tacitly required a fiction writer to cover. The book will probably be great but what an odd article!
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by citizenpaul on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:28PM (#29017129)
You mean that the author implies that it was Stephenson's duty to write a book about global warming based on the authors self perceived authority to demand it? This toxic attitude is really what I was poking at as I suspected it was the case. That or click bait sensationalism.

There are hundreds of other writers that have written science fiction based on this premise.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by andyjohnson0 on Thursday October 28, 2021 @05:16AM (#29023990)
> You mean that the author implies that it was Stephenson's duty to write a book about global warming based on the authors self perceived authority to demand it?

No, that's not what I meant at all.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by CRConrad on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @06:51AM (#29092991)
But even if it wasn't what you meant, it certainly is an impression one can pretty legitimately get. Maybe more so from the headline than the whole contents (can't quite recall, already a few days since I read it); but that only shows that the constant clickbaitification of headlines sucks.
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by drclau on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:09AM (#29010986)
I have just finished yesterday Greg Egan’s Permutation City (a great read, even though I wouldn’t say it’s for everyone), which was published in ‘94, and I was pleasantly surprised to see the climate change theme in the story, although it was not part of the main theme.

More so, cloud computing is present and quite important in this book, even though I don’t think the term was used as such. It’s essentially distributed compute that you rent to run your code, and prices vary based on demand. The climate change theme comes into play here, when all compute is rented to run weather simulations in an effort to fight climate change.

There’s also software that edits facial expressions, for instance to eliminate signs of stress during a video call (we’re not quite there yet, but FaceTime’s Eye Contact feature seems to be a step towards that). This, again, is from ‘94.

I do wonder often how much of the current tech is inspired by [hard] SF. Another example seems to be Elon Musk’s Neuralink, which very likely was inspired by Iain M. Banks “neural lace” from the Culture series.

Edit: typing this on phone, and I edited a few times for corrections and to add more info.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by andyjohnson0 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:13AM (#29011006)
Permutation City and Diaspora are excellent books by Egan.
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by mypastself on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:50AM (#29011194)
I enjoyed Permutation City, Quarantine, and some of his earlier short story collections, even at their most difficult. But I quit Diaspora fairly early.

I worked really hard to understand the first chapter’s dense descriptions of ridges, grids and virtual machine elements, all the while thinking how a single picture would have made things far simpler.

When a later chapter started describing a torus in great detail I thought, if I’m going to be working this hard, I’d rather be reading a technical book about a topic I was interested in. So I did, and I remember it was way easier, and more edifying.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by andyjohnson0 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:07AM (#29011624)
I'd broadly agree with your comments about Diaspora. The characterisation isn't great, but what makes it so impressive to me is the colossal (time, space) scale of the thing.
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by drclau on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:16AM (#29011032)
Was wondering what to pick next. I’ll pick Diaspora, thanks to your comment. :)
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:44AM (#29010570)
I can't decide if I need a browser extension that just deletes the word "finally" from headlines, as it never adds anything but unnecessary drama or actively blocks the whole article from my view on the basis that it's probably clickbait bullshit.

Has anyone written an AI yet that can read the article and tell you that before you waste your time?

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by adwn on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @04:43AM (#29010858)
Next week on HN: This AI can finally tell you whether an article is a waste of your time
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by drstewart on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @04:03AM (#29010681)
Don't forget about the word "quietly". Usually trying to insinuate something shady is happening but always leaves me thinking: "Would I really expect them to broadcast this loudly?"
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by mejutoco on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:00AM (#29010937)
I have you covered! I developed this half-joking half serious extension to remove the word 'actually', but it already expanded to include words like 'literally. (each word is configurable individually)

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/actually-no-remove...

If you comment on the webstore page with the request to add finally I will add the feature this week.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by Fnoord on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:50AM (#29010603)
'Finally' denotes op'ed, subjectivity by author of Wired article. It signals those who care about global warming to click, while those who don't care are more inclined to skip. Ie. it has a use.

While you're at it you can do the same with questionmark / questions, cause the answer is probably "No.".

HN does use software to (de)prioritize certain titles and URLs.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by foo27928 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:32AM (#29011112)
"finally" is very much appropriate. No need for petitions. The article quotes Stephenson: “I'm a guy who found a niche writing fiction about technical and scientific topics. It seemed odd to me that I should get to the end of my career and never take a whack at it.”
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by ycombinete on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:49AM (#29010600)
It made me think of David Chappelle's famous "where's Ja?!" bit [0].

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mo-ddYhXAZc

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by disneygibson on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:02AM (#29010947)
Because for many people (this author included), this topic is akin to a religion, complete with holy literature (sci-fi) and a high priesthood (scientists and sci-fi writers.) So when a "god" like Stephenson (the word god is used in the article to describe him) doesn't preach about the imminent End of Times, everyone gets nervous.

If you think I'm exaggerating, here is an excerpt:

But a few weeks ago, at dinner, a conversation with my teenage son went awry. I was trying to talk to him about possible college plans, and he wouldn't engage. I pushed. We gotta get started, I explained. Applications. Money. Campus visits.

And he said, “Frankly, I just feel sort of nihilistic about it.”

I followed up. About what?

Well, it turned out—the whole thing, really. College, jobs, the ecosphere, the future. The boomers blasted it all into oblivion while Gen X screwed around on the internet.

Here's where I blew it. Instead of giving him the we're-all-in-this-together-change-the-future speech, I said, “Kiddo, I think there's a chance that when all this shakes out, some people will get to be inside the dome and most people won't, and I'm just hoping you'll get inside the dome before they shut the door.”

Like I said, cultish.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by krageon on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:05AM (#29010969)
I don't understand what that quote is supposed to tell the reader about cultish behaviour.
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by disneygibson on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:07AM (#29010977)
I will add more of the quote.

The author was talking to his son, who was feeling unmotivated about going to college because the world was ending soon. The author's reply was the section I quoted.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by krageon on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:16AM (#29011036)
Within this context it reads as a father instructing his child about the importance of learning so they can recognise opportunity when it arises. Is it culty because of the dome?
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by disneygibson on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:22AM (#29011061)
The exact same conversation could be had at an obscure religious cult ranch in the middle of the desert. Remember, these people are completely serious.

“Dad, I’m depressed and unmotivated about going to college.”

“Son, the world is ending in the near future in sci-fi fashion and I want to make sure you survive in the dome.”

No matter how bad climate change is, I can assure you, we won’t be living in a dome to escape the hellscape in 20 years. People who believe this are exhibiting cultish behavior.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by krageon on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:12AM (#29011304)
The "fi" part in "sci-fi" stands for "fiction". While it could be said that we're not sure about precisely how the world is ending, we can certainly make some projections. Making sure your children can survive even a pessimistic projection isn't necessarily cultish behaviour, especially if it's based on evidence-based modeling (whether or not this specific example is I cannot say, I'm not terribly interested in finding out what fresh hell the future has planned for me. Reality as it is is bad enough).
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by disneygibson on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:19AM (#29011336)
My complaint is that the author has forgotten what fiction is and seems to think it correlates to reality.
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by dennis_moore on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:17AM (#29011325)
What are you talking about? I'm sure he's being metaphorical.
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by rini17 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:00AM (#29011239)
Do you have anything to support the assurance? If we have to spend whole lives indoors with A/C and CO2 scrubbers that is practically as bad as the domes.

(It is likely that elevated CO2 levels will harm human cognition, it isn't widely known probably because it's too depressing. There are counterarguments like "oh that happens only above 1000ppm we're far from that" but they're based only on short-term experiments.)

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by disneygibson on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:18AM (#29011332)
Do you honestly believe that everyone will spend their lives inside an air conditioned room and with CO2 scrubbers?

My assurance is reality. Reality isn’t a science fiction novel.

Interestingly you only get these absurd predictions from a very narrow group of people, which lines up quite well with what my original comment said. It’s a religious movement, not an accurate assessment of climate science.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by rini17 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:57AM (#29012008)
The reality is that worldwide CO2 production isn't going to decline anytime soon. What's absurd about predicting that? And if it's only agenda of narrow group of people, where are the majority voices supported by research?
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by disneygibson on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:47AM (#29012589)
Because absolutely no climate science says that increased CO2 in the next twenty years will lead to humans living entirely inside with AC’d units? Again, this is basic science.

The real effects of climate change will be difficult enough. We don’t need to waste energy on inventing fantastical ones.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by rini17 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:03AM (#29012774)
Dismissing everything you don't like as fantasies is the surest way to eventual harm.

https://penntoday.upenn.edu/news/continued-CO2-emissions-wil...

Combine this with wetbulb temperatures which force everyone to stay in airconditioned indoors for weeks or months in large part of world (this too is supported by climate science). Fantasies? I hope so but expect the worst.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by disneygibson on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:54AM (#29013305)
You’ve moved the goal posts about five times now. First it was our entire lives indoors. Now it’s just a few months a year in some parts of the world. First it was in the next 20 years. Now it’s by the end of the century.

A single study that predicts brain damage from CO2 “by the end of the century” is pure speculation at this point. The link you shared even says it’s still very unclear what the effect is.

I’ll say it again; the actual science says that climate change is a serious problem. It doesn’t say that we are headed into the apocalypse in the next decade.

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by rini17 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @11:19AM (#29014473)
Ok sorry I was unclear. In 20 years it could be just a few months indoors, and by end of century all the time.

The actual paper linked from the article links to some research like: "systematic relationships were found between most of the cognitive function scores and CO2 concentration, including from 550–945 ppm". Thinking that in 20 years we could go over 550ppm outside certainly isn't a fantasy, or?

Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by justin66 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:43AM (#29012535)
Humor and hyperbole (both of which you've apparently failed to recognize) are not the central traits of cults.
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by disneygibson on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:58AM (#29012727)
The author uses the word apocalypse at least five times in the article. I don’t think he was being hyperbolic.
Re:Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming by bloat on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:04AM (#29010958)
See also the use of the word "now", which seems to imply "Oh God, after everything else, what are they up to now?" as in (from the Daily Mail) "Now police blame victims for being burgled!"