News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by hncurious on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @12:21PM (#29002339)
Mob: She's a witch!

Accused: Hold on. Let me explain. Some frogs hibernate and it was merely awaking after...

You: Just apologize. You were holding a frog that reanimated. Whether you intended to appear a witch or not, the mob thinks you are. That's what matters. So just bend to their demands and all will be well. The mob won't grow in power with yet another victim. Certainly they will never come for me. I'm an ally. Educate yourself. Be better.

Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by nynx on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @12:26PM (#29002397)
Be honest with what the situation is. This is completely about whether he used language that some people found offensive. They have the right to be offended, have the right to ask for an apology, and have the right to ask the university to demand an apology. No one is threatening death or bodily harm. It’s not a witch hunt.

shadowgovt phrased it well lower in the comment section:

> Honestly, Yale's administration is trying to help.

> This individual's major risk surface isn't what Yale will do to him... It's that his peers have filed his name away in their personal Rolodex-analog as "Someone very, very clueless about tone and reading a room." i.e. "Someone I don't want as partner in my law firm."

Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by xboxnolifes on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @12:06PM (#29002139)
> Look, if you use some particular language that other people find offensive, even if you didn’t mean it that way, just apologize.

I disagree. You apologize if you believe you did something wrong. If you do not feel what you did was wrong, do not apologize.

Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by nynx on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @12:13PM (#29002236)
He’s certainly free to do that and that seems to be what ultimately happened. That being said, he’s free to experience the social consequences of showing himself to be unable or unwilling to read a room.
Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by xboxnolifes on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @02:24PM (#29004208)
It's not just about being "free" to do something. It's about not putting out the fake "I'm sorry you are offended" apology.
Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by Aliabid94 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:46AM (#29001851)
Being offended does not give you the undeniable power to demand apologies.
Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by whoknew1122 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:52AM (#29001930)
You can demand anything at any time. Doesn't mean you're getting one. He said something that people took offense to. They demanded an apology. He didn't apologize. I'm not sure why this necessitated a blog article, much less one circulated on Hacker News.

For what it's worth, I'm a white guy who grew up in poverty and have seen more than one trap house. I'm uncomfortable about the use of trap house here, because it's ridiculous. Yale Law School is one of the most privileged places in the US. It demeans the experiences of people who have been subjected to actual poverty and drug-infested areas to equate anything at Yale with a trap house.

Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by CodeGlitch on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @02:19PM (#29004127)
Don't forget that the administrators threatened that the situation "could escalate". Being in his position I would read that as being expelled.

It's important and should be on hacker news because one day they'll come for you.

Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by unethical_ban on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:56AM (#29001991)
Was it such an offensive message that it deserved letters to administration claiming the author is racially insensitive? Was it so offensive, that it required school administrators to hurriedly draft a template apology to make it go away?

As the author said, the term trap house has a common colloquial meaning among certain people; whether one finds it offensive from a "triggering" perspective, it is not in good faith to ignore that and have the person kicked out of a career, in my opinion.

Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by blitzar on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:50AM (#29001903)
They are as free to be offended or request an appology as the author is to say what they like. Everyone is quite litterally free.

Everyone is also free to judge these people on their actions.

Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by shadowgovt on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:53AM (#29001944)
From the ancient human custom of group shunning to the modern dragging, when a person is outside the good graces of their community, they are under threat.

When lots of people are offended, they have the power to refrain from interacting with an individual. And we are social creatures.

Practically speaking, one's power to demand an apology is proportional to what happens to the demandee if you decide they aren't worth interacting with in the future. If you're a social, political, or corporate leader, or a member of a union (formal or informal / social), it can be quite a lot of power.

Re:Why I didn’t apologize for that Yale Law School email by blitzar on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:48AM (#29001865)
No offence, but ...

Not being racist, but ...

Not a conservatives are being oppressed rant, but ...

Its almost a cliche