News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by marginalia_nu on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:29AM (#28998209)
Ok, if as you say, human rights can just be declared arbitrarily by anyone and have no special significance or legal power beyond being a fancy way of saying "I want this", why would anyone care about human rights in the first place?
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by ratww on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:36AM (#28998257)
People care because they read the thing and thought it sounded like a bunch of good ideas to implement in their own neck of the woods. Some politician brings it home a copy and tries to make law, representatives vote. That's it.

People routinely suggest new human rights and some people agree and others disagree. There is no higher court or secret world parliament deciding your life.

You asked "How do rights become true or false?". Well, by becoming new laws in individual countries.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by marginalia_nu on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:46AM (#28998327)
Returning to the post, if Tor is claiming "Privacy Is A Human Right", and Facebook (hypothetically) responds "No It Isn't", can either party be said to be correct?

If neither is correct (or both simultaneously), is it even a meaningful statement about the world to declare a human right like Tor does?

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by ratww on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:53AM (#28998372)
> can either party be said to be correct

Yes. Tor is correct and Facebook is wrong. I said it. Other people might say otherwise, but I'll say they're wrong. (and they are)

In societies it is normal to have disagreements.

What people do is discuss the issue and potentially reach an agreement. Maybe this will become a law somewhere. Maybe it will go into the Universal Declaration, and most countries will implement it. Maybe not. After becoming a law, people will either follow it or not. If they sort of break the law, a judge or peers will decide if they need punishment. Maybe they do, maybe they don't. Who knows.

Life is not a computer program or math equation. Life is a bit hard.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by marginalia_nu on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:01AM (#28998434)
If you say the sky is blue, or that water is wet, or that rock is hard, or that ice is cold, and so forth; I can agree with you because I can use my senses and they tell me the same thing you were telling me.

If you tell me the angular sum of a triangle is 180 degrees, I cannot see it directly with my senses, but I can construct a simple proof with pen and paper that shows me it cannot be any other way than what you told me.

How do you experience the truth of the human right to privacy?

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by ratww on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:05AM (#28998451)
That's a very misleading question. You are comparing law and social constructs with natural science or math equation results. That's not how the world works.

Societies are much more complex than that.

I can try to convince you that this is right, if that's what you're asking. But no, there won't be a math equation or an scientific measurement that proves that it is correct. Because we're humans, not numbers or bits.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by marginalia_nu on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:58AM (#28998762)
Right, but the only things I have access to are the things I can experience. I am of a slight empiricist bent, so if I am to be convinced about something, it needs to at least be related to those sorts of things I have experienced or can experience.

I can't touch something like a social contract or an ideological standpoint, I don't know where it is are or how long it's been there, when it happened, how intense it is, whether it has any properties, whether it was caused or can cause; these things don't appear to be like anything that in any sense can be said to exist. If these things are gods, then for the sake of this conversation let's call my position an agnostic one.

Society is complex, but even complex things are built from the parts we can see and touch, and since our senses are the only means we have for interacting with the world, even impossibly complex things must somehow be relatable back to them (unless there is some additional channel in which knowledge enters our minds?).

If something is so nebulous that it is completely built from things we can't experience in any way other than being told about them, then how can they be said to exist at all, how could we tell this tale apart from complete fiction?

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by ido66667 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:30AM (#28999005)
If you are looking for a proven moral system, there are none. The whole idea of human rights is a product of a certain culture (western europe and its dependencies) just like the Quran or the Bible. You can't really prove something is a human rights, much like you can't prove human rights are the 'correct' moral framework. So it's all opinions really.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by human_bean on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @01:33PM (#29003382)
I would say that Robert M Pirsig made a pretty good case for objective morality with his Metaphysics of Quality. I had never agreed with the notion before (usually the arguments are religious in nature and require faith to accept) but it is the closest I've ever come to accepting objective morality as brute fact. At the very least it is compelling to indulge in and try out, can't say I've ever looked at things in quite the same way since I first finished Lila.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by bobthechef on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @09:59AM (#29000451)
> If you are looking for a proven moral system, there are none.

What do you mean by "prove"? You can easily extend your skepticism to any body of knowledge. The empirical sciences ought not be given a free pass merely because of some unexamined (and incoherent) prejudice like scientism.

Everything can be said to be a matter of opinion, so that does nothing to clarify the subject.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by marginalia_nu on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @10:08AM (#29000581)
This loops back to the question of what we mean when we say a moral statement is true, which is really the heart of what we are investigating.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by ratww on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @04:35AM (#29010818)
A moral statement can be said to be true in a certain societal context, but not in absolute. To understand this truth you have to take into account the body of knowledge and collective experience of a certain society. In this case it's pretty much the entire world. If you ignore it, then yeah, the statement doesn't make sense, but it only doesn't make sense if you choose to ignore the most important part of the discussion and all its participants.

The bigger question here is: why does a moral statement can only be valid when it's valid in absolute? Why does it have to have a proof that's easy enough for a person that's willingly choosing to ignore knowledge?

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by marginalia_nu on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @10:02AM (#29000480)
Right, but doesn't that inevitably lead to nihilism? If all value systems are equal, then are any value systems meaningful?

Why do we assert that this-and-that is a human right in such a context?

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by ratww on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:56AM (#29001982)
Why would it lead to nihilism?
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by ido66667 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:16AM (#28998890)
This is simply the is-ought problem. You cannot prove a moral statement from observation or measurement of nature. This does mean that indeed Facebook and Tor would be on equivalent grounds. The judgment between them is up to you.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by bobthechef on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @10:06AM (#29000550)
All judgement is "up to me". And how does your claim about observation and measurement fair when subjected to its own criteria?

Also, the "is-ought" problem follows from a particular (very problematic) metaphysics. It does not follow from an Aristotelian understanding of metaphysics.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @10:47AM (#29001085)
> Also, the "is-ought" problem follows from a particular (very problematic) metaphysics.

No, it flows from propositional logic, which is not a metaphysics. You can't have an “ought” conclusion with only “is” premises.

A metaphysics may assume “ought” axioms and thus support “ought” conclusions from only “is” additional bases, but then you still aren't getting an “ought” from an “is”, you are getting it from the “ought” you assumed with your metaphysics.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by marginalia_nu on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @10:20AM (#29000736)
> the "is-ought" problem follows from a particular (very problematic) metaphysics

Why is it problematic?

> It does not follow from an Aristotelian understanding of metaphysics.

Aristotle's metaphysics does also carry some baggage. It is contingent on an unmoved mover/active intellect that creates not only motion but purpose in the universe.

Although his ethics can broadly be taken at face value as long as you agree with the proposition that your purpose is to flourish as a human. It does seem to work pretty well, although the question he was truly answering was how to be a happy individual, whereas the meaning of ethics has shifted over the millennia to deal more with civic virtues than personal ones.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by Cederfjard on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:51AM (#28998708)
You can’t, so you just have to accept that in some senses, reality is imperfect, in shades of gray, and sometimes irreconcilable with itself. You will not find a neat proof showing how to make everyone live in peace, harmony and happiness. But as humans we can try to do the best we can, which inevitably will be a long series of compromises.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by johnisgood on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:20AM (#28998931)
I do not know why you are being down-voted, the whole subject is interesting. The question could lead to great discussions.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by marginalia_nu on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @09:59AM (#29000449)
It's understandable. It's uncomfortable to have the things you believe to be true brought into the light and scrutinized.

They killed Socrates for asking too many of these types of questions.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by ratww on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @04:17AM (#29010745)
It's not uncomfortable. It's just that the questions are boring and littered with fallacies and incorrect assumptions. People isn't having a rich discussion, as we have to correct a lot of misconceptions. The downvotes are perfectly understandable.

This is the opposite of Socrates. He started from the premise that he knew nothing. In this discussion here, you're asking questions from the premise that already know most things about the subject. Also, this is not why Socrates was killed, please do some reading instead of jumping on another meme.

Also: comparing yourself to Socrates for asking fallacious questions is peak Hacker News. Don't think I ever saw such arrogance.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by johnisgood on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:47PM (#29018207)
The way I read it, it was already obvious to me that analytic propositions are different from synthetic propositions (using the terms as used by Kant or David Hume).

I merely just wished to have a discussion on how we do determine what right "should be" a human right, and what makes it a human right, or simply, a right to begin with? It is actually quite a lengthy topic, and for example Rothbard has written a lot on how human rights are property rights and so forth. We could have gotten to animal's rights as well! I suppose one could brush it all under the rug with the term "subjective", but I would rather not stop there.

But in any case, this is my only defense for the OP. I have no idea how one would "experience the truth" of a human right, I would need some more answers before I get to know what the OP has meant by it exactly.

As for the Socrates stuff, I have no comment on that.

---

Allow me to quote some Rothbard:

> There are several aspects of this important truth. In the first place, each individual, according to our understanding of the natural order of things, is the owner of himself, the ruler of his own person. Pres­ervation of this self-ownership is essential for the proper develop­ment and well-being of man. The human rights of the person are, in effect, a recognition of each man’s inalienable property right over his own being; and from this property right stems his right to the material goods that he has produced. A man’s right to per­sonal freedom, then, is his prop­erty right in himself.

> But there is another sense in which human rights are really property rights, a sense which is much obscured in our time. Take, for example, the human right of freedom of assembly. Suppose that a certain group wants to demonstrate for a particular idea or bill in a street meeting. This is an expression of the right of as­sembly.

> On the other hand, sup­pose that the police break up the meeting on the ground that traffic is being disrupted. Now, it is not sufficient simply to say that the right of assembly has been abridged by the police for politi­cal reasons. Possibly, this was the case. But there is a real problem here, for maybe traffic was dis­rupted. In that case, how is one to decide between the human right of free assembly and the "public policy" or "public good" of clear and unobstructed traffic?

> In the face of this apparent conflict, many people conclude that rights must be relative rather than ab­solute and have to be curbed sometimes for the common good.

Taken from https://fee.org/articles/human-rights-are-property-rights/.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by davidgay on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:24AM (#29001535)
It's a distraction from the main discussion. And your comments are boring, because this is one of the most discussed epistemological questions and you are bringing exactly zero new insights to it.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by johnisgood on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:53PM (#29018288)
But others may have brought some insights into it, right? To me, that would be a "success".
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by actually_a_dog on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:05AM (#28998815)
What if I then draw a triangle on the surface of a sphere with an angle sum of 270 degrees?

All you're saying here is that we've agreed on a principle that implies what you're saying is true. This is the exact same as what the other commenter is saying.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by numpad0 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:25AM (#28998971)
My answer will be "not immediately, but I state that I understand that the history has proven the former to be correct, and I fully believe our collective will and the future continues to prove that".

Feel free to call BS on it. Kinda is. Ultimately it's the human might that supports rights.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by memling on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @09:39AM (#29000250)
> Well, by becoming new laws in individual countries.

Can a country create a right for more living space for some of its citizens?

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by powersnail on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:46AM (#28998328)
Like all social constructs, they come into being when a bunch of humans collectively believe in them.

The social significance depends on how the believers act. Some discipline themselves, some try to persuade others, some start a war, some try to push through legislations.