News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by mdp2021 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:03AM (#28998030)
> How do rights become true or false

Not «true or false»: part of the "social contract".

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by marginalia_nu on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:08AM (#28998060)
This doesn't really change the question.

If two people (or groups) are arguing over whether something is part of the social contract, how can we tell which of them is correct?

This also seems to go against the spirit of human rights. How can we motivate minority rights in a society that feels justified persecuting minorities (i.e. in a society where minority rights are not part of the social contract)?

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by mdp2021 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:30AM (#28998214)
> arguing over whether something is part of the social contract

What?! The contract is defined in its normative constitution. It's written! It's dynamic - your service provider sends you an update to the contract: you don't like it, you cease rapport.

The issue we have today is with the relative lack of options.

In the case of the DoHR: once accepted, that is part of the contract. Effectiveness to be defined (for example, inconsistencies with a [Statal legal] Constitution are noted by a higher court which can nullify proposed laws).

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by chii on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:12AM (#28998090)
> how can we tell which of them is correct?

might makes right. That has always been the case in nature, because it's the only way that worked so far.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by Radim on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:04AM (#28998445)
But what is might here?

Historically, "might" correlated near perfectly with "population size". From Sumer onward, the size of your army & slave count determined right-making (in the UN sense). Exceptions due to technology innovations were sparse and short-lived.

Therefore subsequent evolution has been mostly around how to manage large groups of humans, through "social contracts" and various domestication measures. The social configurations that managed better, won over those that did worse.

In other words, huge centralized states have been a huge evolutionary success. There are pretty much no independent ("sovereign" when it comes to right-making, UN or otherwise) small groups of humans any more, they got all gobbled up by superstates.

But I wonder if our institutions have fully caught up to the fact that the number of humans is near-irrelevant now. With the right technology, a small group can dominate millions, billions. And their necessary supply chain is tiny, relative to the purported UN jurisdiction – by a factor of at least 1000x.

So "democracy as right making" is at DIRECT ODDS with "might as right making". I wonder how this clash between where the power resides (technology and its homeostatic supply chain) and where people think it resides (themselves and their divine individuality) will play out. The emperor has no clothes.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by marginalia_nu on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:20AM (#28998129)
If you are correct and it's all down to majorities bullying minorities around, how can we motivate human rights? Especially since they seem to have been instituted to prevent majorities bullying minorities around.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by po1nt on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:48AM (#28998339)
Reduce power of the majority by collectively limiting power of government.
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by mytailorisrich on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @08:31AM (#28999564)
That's exactly what having basic rights and human rights does.

Of course this is a bit circular reasoning because this works only if everyone abides by these rules, so in practice protects only against relatively 'mild' infringements and situations (i.e. the people are expected to be reasonable enough not to vote extremists in power... if not, all bets are off but that's true of all laws)

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by po1nt on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:30AM (#29001618)
Don't blame the player, blame the game. Democracy will always converge into extremism the more power government has over people's lives. If you become reliant on government acting violently against the power minority and let government increase it's power, it will always lead to this.

It's self feeding problem. The only solution is slowly to deny government power over people.

Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by tremon on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:19AM (#28998917)
And what happens when government stops being the majority power in a country? Should we still work to limit the power of government, or should we work towards limiting the power of the new majority?
Re:Privacy Is a Human Right by po1nt on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:25AM (#29001549)
The issue is whether the new majority power gives itself monopoly of violence.