Re:Arrow and the Impossibility Theorem (2012) [pdf]
by mdp2021 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @09:59AM
(#29000458)
Disambiguation. If 34% (or even 49%) claiming A>B>C made A the winner, 66% (large majority, or even 51%, simple majority) explicitly claimed that C>A ...
That «roughly 2/3 of the electorate would prefer one of the others» means that whatever candidate is chosen (say, A), the large majority states that a single different candidate (in this case, C) is better than the winner.
There is clearly a paradox.
Imagine you have a voting public whose preferences are (roughly) 1/3 prefer A > B > C, 1/3 prefer B > C > A, and 1/3 C > A > B. Fisrt off, it's quite obvious that there is no real "right" thing to do, whichever candidate wins, roughly 2/3 of the electorate would prefer one of the others. Fine as far as it goes. But let's say there are slightly more A > B > C, and A is declared the winner. Arrow seems to think it is a bug that only people's knowledge of B allows A to defeat C, but obviously it's a feature.