News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EFF co-founder John Gilmore removed from org's Board by rasengan on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:18PM (#28993868)
Freedom is serious business and worth dying for. If our freedoms online are taken, make no mistake, it will be war.
Re:EFF co-founder John Gilmore removed from org's Board by blagie on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:35PM (#28994028)
I agree, but...

Whose freedom? And what is freedom?

Market dynamics support corporations which can generate the largest numbers of ad clicks. You can't run an organization which doesn't ultimately conform to market dynamics. That leads to polarization, hate, and misinformation. Do we want to go down that path?

Are corporations people? Should corporations have freedom-of-speech? Should corporations be free to lie? Should government employees? Should corporations be free to engage in speech which is known to actively harm people?

I really don't know.

I do feel like some forms of intentional lying should be illegal. If a government employee says something, or an academic does, I should be able to trust they're not being intentionally untruthful. Where does that line lie? I don't know.

I also feel like individuals should have real freedom of speech. Not just freedom from government prosecution after speech, but freedom from economic prosecution, and to some extent, social ostracization.

I feel like we need a serious discussion here, though.

Re:EFF co-founder John Gilmore removed from org's Board by J5892 on Monday October 25, 2021 @07:05PM (#28994306)
War with whom?

The government? Tech companies? ISPs?

All are in some ways restricting certain freedoms, while enabling others.

And what freedoms are you afraid of being taken that have not already been taken in some form?

I'm absolutely not disagreeing with you. I support full and absolute internet freedom. I have the ability to put absolutely anything I want on the internet with zero restrictions, but depending on what it is and how I put it there, there are many ways it may then cause me to lose freedom in some way.

Which one should lead to war?

Re:EFF co-founder John Gilmore removed from org's Board by Vecr on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @01:54AM (#28996872)
"This represents a clear and present danger to our constitutionally guaranteed freedom to be online."