Re:Economics focus: Don’t look down
by jerf on Thursday August 18, 2011 @10:30AM
(#2899280)
"why do poor middle Americans support policies that harm them in the short term?"
Actually, asking the question that way leads you to another answer; they believe the policies will benefit them in the long term. Some people may observe, for instance, that an extensive welfare state may have an apparently economic beneficial effect in strictly monetary terms for those on the bottom but that it has a very corrosive effect on almost every other social measurement. Or that the growth penalty you take in supporting the welfare state is complicit in itself keeping the welfare recipients poor enough to need welfare in the first place. Or an awareness either conscious or otherwise that a democracy can't survive long with the majority voting themselves benefits from a minority, regardless of what other arguments in its favor it may have.
This paradox is better phrased as "people are voting against what I think is their best interest, what gives?" in which case the answer immediately becomes obvious: They don't agree about what constitutes their self-interest. And given that they are where they are and you aren't, perhaps one might take at least a moment to consider a motive other than stupidity or error.
Actually, asking the question that way leads you to another answer; they believe the policies will benefit them in the long term. Some people may observe, for instance, that an extensive welfare state may have an apparently economic beneficial effect in strictly monetary terms for those on the bottom but that it has a very corrosive effect on almost every other social measurement. Or that the growth penalty you take in supporting the welfare state is complicit in itself keeping the welfare recipients poor enough to need welfare in the first place. Or an awareness either conscious or otherwise that a democracy can't survive long with the majority voting themselves benefits from a minority, regardless of what other arguments in its favor it may have.
This paradox is better phrased as "people are voting against what I think is their best interest, what gives?" in which case the answer immediately becomes obvious: They don't agree about what constitutes their self-interest. And given that they are where they are and you aren't, perhaps one might take at least a moment to consider a motive other than stupidity or error.