I run some (low-traffic) websites. I don't collect any information about anyone. It's not essential.
If you want to have a newsletter, or offer a service where people log in and want to recover their password, you'll need at least an email address. Can you verify that every email address is exclusively used by people 13+?
re: collecting IP addresses: I run my web sites behind Nginx and does have rolling logs, but I ignore IP addresses.
For your e-mail use case, I think a reasonable compromise is asking if the user is older than 13 and what alternative is there but to trust them? Personally, I think that collecting e-mail addresses for people signing up for a newsletter is a great example of when it is perfectly fine to collect private data.
We all see how incompetent the government is when it comes to understanding technology and how it works (see the Missouri governor clamoring to prosecute someone for “hacking” because they used view source), so remember when you’re asking for greater regulation who it is that’s going to be doing the regulating.
That said, I am not suggesting that businesses should or could do this. Some businesses are required through regulations to capture IP addresses of their customers at a minimum.
Children can only participate with these companies because the product is 'free'. Same with p*rn and free2play games: eliminate the 'free' component to effectively block them from children (at least without parental consent).
Idea, browsers would implement parent control, so when you setup a child account on your kid device the OS will store the age of the user, the browsers would read this. Then in the request (maybe depending or region or whatever protocol) the browser can tell you if the user age is <13 or other interval.
So this means the browsers need to collaborate with the OS and the parent has the responsibility to setup the correct user account for the user in the OS, for older OS the parent will have to setup this setting directly in browser and setup the browser in a "child" mode.
I have a YouTube playlist of videos I'd like to show my kids. It turns out that YouTube will not allow videos marked as "intended for children" to be added to a playlist, even by an account that belongs to a adult. So the only videos I can put in that playlist for my kids are ones YouTube thinks are NOT for kids.
You could ask everyone to confirm their age with eID.
- "can maybe connect sensitive data to some persons"
to
- "can absolutely connect sensitive data to every user unless they really go out of their way to avoid it"
How would that work in practice? A lot of us here operate websites. Your website gets a request. How are you supposed to tell the age of the person that request came from? Maybe Google / Facebook have enough data to identify the person and their age, but ironically, they would have to collect information about them to determine that it's a person they shouldn't collect information about.
Certainly no child in the history of the Internet has ever lied to a website when asked their age.