When the article includes the statement "Nice guys do not necessarily finish last, but they do finish a distant second in terms of earnings", it is a sign of either:
1. Imprecise writing, or 2. Wrong conclusions.
If their conclusions are wrong, then the article is a waste of bits. If their writing is imprecise, then just how imprecise are the generalizing statements that cannot be disproved with an obvious counterexample?
In either case, the article looks like all noise and no signal to me.
Doesn't show much by itself, but then neither does trotting out an old saw.
The terminology used in the article ("disagreeable", "mean", etc) is imho too emotionally loaded for proper understanding of the phenomenon. Most people reading this article see the takeaway as "assholes finish first" and are (rightly so) conflicted about trading their souls for a couple gold coins. The real lesson, I think, is to realize that to get anything significant done, you will eventually have to piss off some people you care about at some point. They could be your employees, partners, customers or even family. But this is alright, we piss each off all the time. It's ok, it's a part of life. Just don't be a jerk about it.
> The hypotheses were supported across four studies.
I wonder which study Warren Buffet, that disagreeable guy, fell into?