News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by fartcannon on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:37PM (#28960850)
Saying, "Don't call this FUD" up top doesn't prevent this from being possibly the most blatent FUD I've seen in a long time.

Check if your hardware supports your OS before you buy it. Guess what? Then it all works great. What a waste of time.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by vadfa on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:41PM (#28960893)
People are used to Windows where literally all hardware works. So that statement is not that evident.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by mixedCase on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:51PM (#28961059)
>People are used to Windows where literally all hardware works

Hahaha fuck no. I spent two weeks trying to get a Lenovo Y50's touchpad to work properly on modern Windows. It's impossible. Official drivers are unmaintained and whatever you get whether generic or frankensteined-in works terrible compared to the out of the box experience on a Linux distro.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by colesantiago on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:53PM (#28961084)
Just get/buy a PC pre-installed with Windows?

Don't most people do this?

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by nybble41 on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:08PM (#28961291)
You could equally well get or buy a PC pre-installed with Linux where someone else made sure everything was well-supported. It's not that Windows has inherently better hardware support due to its architecture—rather, hardware manufacturers put in the effort to ensure that their (new) hardware can be used with the latest few versions of Windows, since they would otherwise lose a large part of their target market.

On the other hand, Linux tends to be much better at supporting older hardware that the manufacturers are no longer interested in selling, as well as working across a broader range of hardware platforms ranging from embedded IoT devices to supercomputers.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by bkberry352 on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:01PM (#28961199)
lol, family member's acer laptop (pre-installed with Windows) had audio driver issues to the point where the audio output jack simply doesn't work. No drivers are available for the machine b/c it's pre-installed, so why would there be issues?

The audio out works perfectly under ubuntu

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by realusername on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:15PM (#28961383)
> People are used to Windows where literally all hardware works. So that statement is not that evident.

I wouldn't be so confident, I had my fair share of crappy drivers on windows as well to the point if that the hardware is old, there's a good chance that it will run smoother on Linux.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by rattlesnakedave on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:06PM (#28961276)
This is correct. The "happy path" for a new linux installation is much worse than for windows. It's gotten much better over the last decade, but it's still much harder.

Further, if you really want to drive adoption the linux onboarding process has to be better than the windows onboarding process, which is a massively difficult because the windows process is "purchase a computer, hit the power button, and watch the OS as configured by the manufacturer boot."

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by throwawayninja on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:53PM (#28961079)
I have anecdata of the opposite: my ThinkPad T590 cannot install windows with the .iso from microsoft, you need hardware drivers for the NVMe SSD off another disk during the install. I think windows and linux are about equal in terms of hardware support, with windows trending more towards good support tomorrow's hardware (it works when the new product launches) and linux needing 1-2 weeks before the new hardware gets a driver update + packages are updated.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by itvision on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @08:09AM (#28999372)
> needing 1-2 weeks

Sometimes up to several years or never.

Are VirtualBox and VMWare host drivers included in the Linux kernel? Granted they are not "drivers" per se but anyways.

OK, let's talk about hardware: literally thousands of WiFi adapters continue not to be supported by the Linux kernel some of which were released as early as five years ago.

And then, if you have a Windows driver you know it works and it's full featured.

The Linux driver may offer very rudiment support just to make something work.

So, it's not so simple. Far from it.

[dead]
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by vadfa on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:57PM (#28961149)
Why would anybody want to install Windows on a Nintendo Wii?
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by selfhoster11 on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:12PM (#28961353)
Why not? A true hacker would consider it.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by silisili on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:41PM (#28960902)
Exactly. Or, just buy an integrated system from people who support Linux

Example - Intel. I've never had a single hardware support problem with a NUC. Intel processor, Intel video, Intel wifi, Intel bluetooth. All supported right in the kernel, out of the box.

AMD is getting there, too. I currently run a 4x4 with ryzen and vega, and an Intel ax200. All peachy.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by nescioquid on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:01PM (#28961980)
Twenty years ago, I had fun building new Linux systems. Today, I just want to use the system for doing other things (I don´t need another hobby), so when it was time to replace the old Debian Thinkpad, I bought a Darter Pro from System76.

I expected an experience similar to buying from a MSFT OEM or an Apple macbook (price was certainly comparable), however, I had to spend a fair amount of time getting _basic_ things to work (wifi - Intel - kept cutting out after a few minutes, problems with graphics, driving external monitors, etc). I think System76 probably did the best they could, but they don´t have a silver bullet for the problems discussed in TFA.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by SavantIdiot on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:54PM (#28961112)
Anecdata: I have an intel/dell laptop and bluetooth is a trainwreck on Focal Fossa, let alone display modes and orientation changes. Video playback in FireFox works sometimes, sometimes i need to reboot because it freezes and then won't play again even if I kill the process (I think it is related to going into suspend with a video paused). Yeah, I'm just one person, but damn it is frustrating to do anything else but dev work on linux.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by heavyset_go on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:02PM (#28961217)
You're running a two year old kernel on Focal. Try something newer. I have Intel WiFi and Bluetooth and they work perfectly fine on Linux, as does video playback on Firefox.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by SavantIdiot on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:54PM (#28962611)
Lol. ~30 years of effort and the answer is still: "Download the latest version."

Linux is a workhorse, not a Windows replacement for the unwashed masses.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by heavyset_go on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:41PM (#28963108)
This is like using Windows 7 and complaining when it's Windows 10 that has compatibility with your hardware.

LTS releases are explicit that they have limited hardware support, that is if they even attempt to backport new/updated hardware support at all. That's the point of Ubuntu's LTS Hardware Enablement (HWE) program[1], although it isn't perfect and I wouldn't rely on it for hardware support.

[1] https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Kernel/LTSEnablementStack

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by SavantIdiot on Friday October 22, 2021 @07:43PM (#28964192)
20.04 is literally the latest LTS version of Ubuntu. Windows 7 is TWELVE YEARS OLD. You're analogy is garbage.

On top of that, I've run the auto updater that comes with the GUI (does more than sudo apt update).

If that isn't sufficient to use 4 year-old bluetooth headphones that are older than the OS, and FireFox to watch Netflix, it is far, far worse than Windows. Look, I really want this to succeed, but be honest, it's far behind Windows and Mac.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by heavyset_go on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:30PM (#28965144)
I didn't make the comparison because of its age, but because it's a version of Windows that came before 10, and I forgot Windows 8 even existed. Fill in Windows 8 or 8.1 or whatever for Windows 7.

IMO, your average desktop user's use case isn't served well by an LTS if they plan on using relatively recent hardware, peripherals or software. LTS desktop releases suit Canonical's corporate customers' needs well, though, which is why they were released in the first place. A distribution that uses up-to-date software suits most use cases.

Bluetooth headphone support is something that bit me in the past, as well, but it's an issue that was solved with PipeWire. Ubuntu 20.04 still uses PulseAudio.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by itvision on Saturday October 23, 2021 @09:59AM (#28968567)
Windows 7 has long been unsupported, Windows 8.1 support has recently been dropped by most OEMs as well since Microsoft has deprecated Windows 8.1 earlier than expected.

Four years ago anything you bought was fully supported by Windows 7 and 8.1 aside from lazy OEMs who refused to provide older OSes' drivers.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by itvision on Saturday October 23, 2021 @09:57AM (#28968540)
> "Download the latest version."

Yeah, and if you're running something like Debian 11, CentOS or Ubuntu LTS the answer will be, "Go compile the latest kernel".

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by bogwog on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:57PM (#28961148)
> Check if your hardware supports your OS before you buy it. Guess what? Then it all works great. What a waste of time.

Who runs into hardware compatibility issues with Linux? People installing it themselves.

Who installs Linux themselves? Tech geeks/enthusiasts.

Who should know better than to install an operating system before checking for hardware support? Tech geeks/enthusiasts.

That's why I can't take those people seriously. If hardware support was a real problem, Apple would have gone out of business long ago. People like that aren't trying to have an honest discussion, they're just trying to bash something they don't like or understand.

There are many issues that need to be overcome in the Linux community before the Linux desktop can go mainstream, but we're not going to find answers to those problems by listening to these people.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by rattlesnakedave on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:03PM (#28961230)
>Who installs Linux themselves? Tech geeks/enthusiasts.

Perhaps this wouldn't be the case if we fixed some of the issues in the article :)

There are plenty of people "on the fence" but problems mentioned in the article (among others) keep them away.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by bogwog on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:09PM (#28961304)
What type of person knows how to install an operating system that isn't a tech geek/enthusiast? Not even Linux, who can install Windows or MacOS on an empty hard drive, but doesn't consider themselves to be a "computer person"?

If the Linux desktop can't take off until my grandma is able to install it herself, then well, yeah it's truly fucked.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by spicybright on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:28PM (#28961533)
If I want something to work on my mac, I look for a mac logo on packaging.

I can assume the company has done proper QA and testing to make sure that's the case.

If I want something to work on a typical linux installation, I have to dig through hardware wikis, pages of forum posts, and be ready to dive into config files in case the info above is wrong.

And even then there can be less of a guarantee

The year of the linux desktop will happen once Ubuntu or whatever distro is most popular has a logo that appears next to the windows and/or mac compatibility stickers.

And to add, if anything, we SHOULD be listening to geek enthusiasts if we want linux to go mainstream. Those are the people actually using it day to day, and the ones that will be installing it on other people's computers.

Do you really think we'll get to mainstream adoption by just ignoring issues techies face that a typical user would also face?

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by bogwog on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:45PM (#28961749)
> The year of the linux desktop will happen once Ubuntu or whatever distro is most popular has a logo that appears next to the windows and/or mac compatibility stickers.

That's wrong and ignorant. I installed Kubuntu on my main desktop ~7 years ago, and have had zero compatibility or stability issues, even through 2 LTS upgrades. If everyone who wanted to try Linux used my exact hardware, the Linux desktop would not suddenly take off.

> And to add, if anything, we SHOULD be listening to geek enthusiasts if we want linux to go mainstream. Those are the people actually using it day to day, and the ones that will be installing it on other people's computers.

> Do you really think we'll get to mainstream adoption by just ignoring issues techies face that a typical user would also face?

Did you reply to the wrong person? I didn't say anything even remotely close to this.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by spicybright on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:55PM (#28961890)
> Who installs Linux themselves? Tech geeks/enthusiasts.

> Who should know better than to install an operating system before checking for hardware support? Tech geeks/enthusiasts.

> That's why I can't take those people seriously. ... we're not going to find answers to those problems by listening to these people.

Am I missing something here? My point is issues techies face are the same as a non techie would. So why wouldn't you listen to that kind of feedback from techies?

It's not like they're complaining about kernel internals or architecture, they're complaining about user experience compared to other mainstream operating systems.

If a linux desktop distro can't or isn't willing to address that, then it's simply not designed for a typical user as much as people want it to be.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by bogwog on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:36PM (#28962436)
Ok I see the mix up. When I said “those people”, I wasnt referring to tech people in general, just the ones that would say things like the Linux desktop is doomed because of hardware support.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by jamesgeck0 on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:52PM (#28963210)
> The year of the linux desktop will happen once Ubuntu or whatever distro is most popular has a logo that appears next to the windows and/or mac compatibility stickers.

That last network card I bought that had a Tux on the box used an unmaintained GPL-but-out-of-kernel driver that no longer compiled on mainline kernels.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by spicybright on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:22PM (#28963503)
Let me refine that then. The sticker needs the same guarantees the windows and macos ones do if it wants to be on the box.

Not just some kind of pandering for market share to get linux users to buy it.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by rvz on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:03PM (#28961233)
Exactly this. These are the exact reasons why users having to 'install Linux distros' these days will always be limited to tech geeks and enthusiasts and not widely adopted as a mainstream desktop.

It also explains why Windows 11 (with WSL) is probably the best Linux distro for the desktop as it is already been 'painfully' admitted. [0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28960864

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by bogwog on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:12PM (#28961348)
> Exactly this. These are the exact reasons why users having to 'install Linux distros' these days will always be limited to tech geeks and enthusiasts and not widely adopted as a mainstream desktop.

I don't think you've thought this through. How many Windows users out there have installed it themselves? How many could install it themselves? How many could complete an installation if somebody else booted up the installer for them on a machine with a single empty hard drive?

The popularity of Windows and MacOS have nothing to do with how easy they are to install, or with "hardware support".

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by rvz on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:45PM (#28961754)
> I don't think you've thought this through.

   are you sure?
> How many...

Windows is pre-installed on the majority of OEM desktops and laptops so there is no 'install' or 'install it themselves' step. Same for Apple computers with macOS and that is 100% a given for users.

ChromeOS succeeded due to this. But given that is going to be replaced by Fuchsia, we are just going to see Google putting Fuchsia on the desktop (and phones) instead.

The reasons why Google decided to migrate is another story but the hint is related to "hardware support" similar to how Apple supports their devices.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by ModernMech on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:48PM (#28961008)
> Check if your hardware supports your OS before you buy it. Guess what? Then it all works great.

Not even then. I have a Ubuntu laptop direct from Dell (who has been selling Ubuntu laptops for 14 years), and every time I go to open it the battery is dead. So it's plugged in constantly. My cats love to sit on the closed lid because of how warm it is. Ostensibly it's asleep, but to the touch I can tell that it's running hot, and that's why it's dead within a few hours of being off the charger, even if it's not "on". I mean, it runs hotter sitting there idle and off than my new Surface does when it's on and compiling my Rust code. That's sad!

This is a laptop direct from a hardware manufacturer who supports Linux. This kind of thing was a problem when hibernation first became a thing. Okay, understandable. But 2+ decades later, in 2021, I can't purchase a Ubuntu laptop directly from a manufacturer that has this figured out. That's a problem for Linux. It's one thing to fall short. It's another to fall short for 2 decades.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by Kafkish on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:49PM (#28961808)
I have a Dell Inspiron with AMD A12 processor that I bought with Windows preinstalled in 2019. Never even booted into Windows, just booted right into a USB stick and installed Elementary OS. Putting the system to Sleep was an issue, but now I have Linux Mint Cinnamon installed on it. No more issue with going to Sleep.

I can expect to use the laptop until it packs up.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by munchler on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:14PM (#28961375)
What does Dell say if you report this as a defect in their product?
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by ModernMech on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:27PM (#28961523)
I'm free to return it, but otherwise they will investigate the issue and get back to me. As if.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by itvision on Saturday October 23, 2021 @09:55AM (#28968525)
> Check if your hardware supports your OS before you buy it. Guess what? Then it all works great. What a waste of time.

Ever opened bugzilla.kernel.org? Ever seen the number of regressions? In the past seven days alone:

https://bugzilla.kernel.org/buglist.cgi?chfield=%5BBug%20cre...

Count the number of "stopped working" - at least a dozen and these are only from the people who have bothered to find the kernel bugzilla and file bug reports which is not an easy feat.

There's no such thing as "checking if your hardware is properly supported under Linux". Everything may stop working at any time.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by rvz on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:51PM (#28961063)
Windows users don't need to check as their hardware is fully supported as soon as they press the ON button on their new PC.

On top of that why waste time installing a distro or playing around with display managers, Linux NVIDIA drivers when WSL does it all on Windows?

The fact is: WSL saves time and makes installing Linux redundant and actually a waste of time.

Oh dear.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by Kafkish on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:53PM (#28961863)
> The fact is: WSL saves time and makes installing Linux redundant and actually a waste of time.

If I ever need to run an OS that spies on me, I'll use Windows, then WSL to tun Linux. But I don't want that, so I run Linux. It's freedom, which is more important for me.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by indymike on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:00PM (#28961178)
> The fact is: WSL saves time and makes installing Linux redundant and actually a waste of time.

Not sure what point you are making here. Yes, you can virtualize and OS and WSL is a nice way to do it?

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by rvz on Saturday October 23, 2021 @07:59AM (#28967593)
> Yes, you can virtualize and OS and WSL is a nice way to do it?

Yes. That's the point. Installing Linux using WSL is several clicks away on the Microsoft Store, rather than wasting hours migrating, rebooting, formatting, dual-booting and then installing a Linux distro on the system.

WSL saves lots of time and makes installing Linux on another partition or in general a waste of time.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by indymike on Saturday October 23, 2021 @09:23AM (#28968150)
If are building both Windows and Linux software, that might be convenient. But not particularly more convenient than any other virtualization layer, just more limited (can't install other oses) and with a difficult to maintain and secure host OS. WSL seems to not compete with dual boot, it is competing with other virtual machine software now that is just nicely dressed vm.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by Spivak on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:52PM (#28961074)
But it's not FUD. These are issues that affect end real-life end users and many of them are hardware independent.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:57PM (#28961919)
> Guess what? Then it all works great.

You know, except for literally all the non-hardware related problems in that list.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by itvision on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @08:07AM (#28999347)
> Saying, "Don't call this FUD" up top doesn't prevent this from being possibly the most blatent FUD I've seen in a long time.

Anything more concrete, please? The entire 12 thousand words piece cannot be wrong considering it's shared so much and contains over three thousand comments most of which share the spirit of the article.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by phendrenad2 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:40AM (#28977788)
"Check if your hardware supports your OS before you buy it"

Have you ever tried this? It's shockingly difficult. Even if someone says "yes this device works under Linux 100%" half the time you'll see ANOTHER post telling you it's garbage on Linux.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by rattlesnakedave on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:08PM (#28961300)
The common path for someone using Linux for home computing is transitioning from windows on hardware they already own.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by pizza234 on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:31PM (#28961576)
This is, unfortunately, not necessarily true (of course, the strategy makes sense).

I "voted with my money", and the result is that my laptop, which is supposed to be the poster child of Linux compatibility, has at least one serious hardware compatibility problem out of the box, along with at least another minor one.

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by Kafkish on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:18PM (#28961425)
The thing is, Linux distros make it super easy to check if your HW will work. Just download the distro you want, transfer to a USB stick. Reboot your PC with it and check any connected HW. If it works with the live system, it will work when installed on the PC.
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by phendrenad2 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:44AM (#28977824)
What happens when you want to upgrade to a new PC? Do you take the live USB stick to the computer store and try to boot it?
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by SassyThrowaway on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:00PM (#28961180)
> Check if your hardware supports your OS before you buy it. Guess what? Then it all works great. What a waste of time.

Say, I am buying Thinkpad T480s and Thinkpad X1 (2018). What would you suggest that I check?

Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by shadowgovt on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:51PM (#28961845)
In this scenario, the fact that Lenovo will sell you a Thinkpad X1 with Linux pre-installed shows there is a solution (how easy it is to get to that solution on your own without just buying one pre-configured from them may be an exercise for the reader). https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/p/laptops/thinkpad/thinkpadx1/x...
Re:Major Linux Problems on the Desktop, 2021 edition by selfhoster11 on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:14PM (#28961377)
Why shouldn't it be expected to work with what I already own?