They are all responsible for placing the idiotic ban on incandescent bulbs to begin with. The federal govt has no business legislating the everyday minutiae of our lives.
You are sadly misinformed; apparently taken in by Tea Party propaganda. There is no "ban" on incandescent bulbs, and never was. The proposed standards, which were bipartisan, were intended to increase the efficiency of incandescents over time.
If there is a physical limitation to the amount of light that can be produced by a light bulb that uses black body emission to generate light, then a standard of efficiency that exceeds that physical limitation is an effective ban on generating light via black body emission.
That's the way Congress loves to roll: they won't explicitly ban something they don't like (so they can save face with their constituents), but they'll do everything they can to make it untenable.
Re:HTC sues Apple over everything
by andrewflnr on Wednesday August 17, 2011 @06:22PM
(#2897206)
In California there is. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/01/24/california-incandes...
Why is having standards on lightbulbs a federal issue? Shouldn't it be best handled by the states? Perhaps the EPA or Department of Energy could write a report or make recommendations; but at the end of the day it should reside in the state.
You want 50 sets of slightly different standards for light bulbs? Surely that is a recipe for chaos and inefficiency.
We do it for cars?
Re:HTC sues Apple over everything
by tedunangst on Wednesday August 17, 2011 @06:17PM
(#2897190)
Not really, cars only have to meet one of two standards, California or EPA.
Why do you think we'd have more for cars?
Re:HTC sues Apple over everything
by tedunangst on Thursday August 18, 2011 @12:13PM
(#2899767)
Say what?
That a good reason.
So you think that each state should have a light bulb plant? If not, then we are talking interstate commerce, which means federal standards.
It is not actually the federal government's job to regulate every detail of every transaction that crosses state lines. The specifics of the lightbulbs are only tangentially related to the commercial transaction and even less connected to the fact that it crosses state lines, so I would hardly consider Congress negligent if it declined to make rules for cross-state light bulb shipping.
Nope, but the light bulb plant can choose which states it wants to sell in and manufacture bulbs that meet those requirements. In fact they may just make one that meets the strictest requirements, and people other states may choose to purchase STATE X efficient bulbs.
Placing the blame on Congress generally spreads the incorrect belief that all legislators and both parties are responsible for criminally stupid stuff like this. They're not.