Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in...
by csee on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:40AM
(#28954938)
Have you seen traditional TA methods applied profitably within a quant framework?
Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in...
by lordnacho on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:19AM
(#28955172)
What I've always missed with "Traditional TA" is a rigorous accounting of how to do it, and what the results are.
You can do this yourself on a spreadsheet:
- Get some data
- Calculate the 50 bar moving average
- apply some rule like "trade when it crosses this or that stat"
- See what the PnL is.
- Think about whether this is a fluke and whether it will keep working.
Somehow none of the ads and articles I see do this completely.
But yes, you can take the same data and use it effectively. Needs more than a spreadsheet, admittedly.
Astrologers look at the positions of the stars and planets. Astronomers look at the positions of the stars and planets.
Over the past centuries, astronomers have discovered such amazing things like the distances to other galaxies, the paths of quite small rocks in our solar system, the age of the universe, redshift, cosmic background radiation, and so on.
TA, basically looking at the numbers that come out of the market, is the same. You can do silly unscientific things with it, or you can apply a falsifiable method and make real progress.
If you go down the scientific route, you will find the same data takes you down a rabbit hole of low latency coding, linear algebra, infrastructure, financial theory (time value of money, optionality), economics, and so forth.