News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by cinntaile on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:39AM (#28954580)
If you had invested in Facebook or Tesla around their IPO you would be a contrarian though. Facebook less so than Tesla maybe, but not a lot of people seemed to believe that they would stick around.
Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by shapefrog on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:02AM (#28956709)
By the very nature of an IPO there is basically 1 seller the company (and in many cases the insiders) who are selling to 10's or 100's of thousands of buyers, private and institutional.

Hint: The contrarian here is not the thousands of people/institutions/funds buying on the float.

Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by cinntaile on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:48AM (#28957148)
It depends on how many would want to invest in those companies and how many wouldn't. If you have 10000 buyers but 100000 that wouldn't touch it with a ten foot pole then those 10000 buyers are still contrarians. (Partly) cashing out isn't by definition contrarian.
Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by shapefrog on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:11AM (#28957396)
Having 0 position is not the opposite of having 100 shares; -100 shares is the opposite.

By your definition owning an iPhone is contrarian, because there are only 1billion people with iPhones.

Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by cinntaile on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:19AM (#28958331)
Contrarian just means holding a position the majority doesn't hold. Although reality is not that clearcut as you aptly pointed out. Most investors didn't think Facebook or Tesla were good investments, hence investing in those stocks is a contrarian position.

To use your example, I would consider choosing to not use a smartphone to be a contrarian position while having an iPhone is not.