News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by caf on Thursday October 21, 2021 @12:55AM (#28940432)
In my estimation, the ultimate problem with hydrogen isn't any of those three - it's that it's simply far less convenient than battery.

Once someone has experienced what it's like to be able to "fill up" overnight at home for all their day-to-day driving, the idea of reverting to the old "visit the fuelling station once a week" routine seems decidedly passe.

It could work for long-haul commercial vehicles though.

Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Thursday October 21, 2021 @04:49AM (#28941972)
Except no one drives at home. Every EV fan still complains about lack of public charging stations. I suspect few people really find home recharging as any kind of game changer.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by magicalhippo on Thursday October 21, 2021 @07:33AM (#28942974)
We've owned an EV for two years and charging at home has been a huge deal, especially for my SO.

She needs to get to bed early, so when hanging out with friends she hated having to go to the gas station on her way home. Often resulting in panic the next day. More than once she ran out of gas cause she forgot to look when driving off in the morning.

It takes about 3 seconds to plug in the car when we get back home, and we never have to worry about running out when we drive away in the morning.

Hydrogen would have to be significantly better in price and range to offset this for our future vehicle purchase. A mere 2x range increase over pure EV won't cut it.

Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Thursday October 21, 2021 @12:32PM (#28946984)
This is just post-hoc rationalization. The extra few minutes of refueling time is hardly a problem.

Even so, eventually you likely will be able to refuel at home since home electrolysis is possible.

Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by magicalhippo on Thursday October 21, 2021 @05:26PM (#28951015)
> This is just post-hoc rationalization.

For you maybe. For my SO I can assure you it's absolutely not.

Having owned an EV for two years now, it's clear that it's been good enough for us. Yes range is a bit limited, but for us it hasn't been an issue. It has some upsides like fairly trivial home-charging if you got a garage.

As such, hydrogen can't just deliver the same to be competitive. Hydrogen will have to deliver more. Longer range at same cost wouldn't be enough for us, the negatives would make it a no-go. So it would have to be longer range for much cheaper.

But I don't see how cost can be significantly cheaper, given the process inefficiencies and infrastructure required.

Looking at the concepts[1] I can't imagine them being cheaper than a home EV charger, which is about 1000-1500 USD installed. Never mind that we don't have any space for such a huge thing.

And I'm doubtful as to how much H2 we'll be able to generate here in Norway during winter.

[1]: https://www.hydrogencarsnow.com/index.php/home-hydrogen-fuel...

Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Thursday October 21, 2021 @06:23PM (#28951547)
Then I will have to disagree. I insist that it is still post-hoc rationalization.

Sooner or later, hydrogen cars will be cheaper to own than a battery car. Once this happens, none of this reasoning will hold up to scrutiny.

Should be noted that you can have hydrogen delivered in the same way propane/LPG can be delivered. In fact, gasoline/petrol could have been delivered since the first days of the automobile. None of these ideas really mattered in the end.

Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by magicalhippo on Thursday October 21, 2021 @07:41PM (#28952196)
> Once this happens, none of this reasoning will hold up to scrutiny.

My point is it can't just be say 20% cheaper to own. It'll have to be much more than that to offset the pain of having to refuel.

Sure, if it's 20% cheaper including having the H2 delivered at home, then we're approaching something that can be considered.

Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Thursday October 21, 2021 @07:53PM (#28952285)
As we are talking about a large ticket item (cars), a 20% difference is a big deal.

As with all fuels, this shouldn't be much more expensive than from a fueling station.

Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by caf on Thursday October 21, 2021 @08:57AM (#28943729)
My experience is that complaints about lack of public charging stations tend to be more from those considering buying an EV than those actually with one.

(Those who drive an EV tend to complain more about the maintenance of the public stations than the number of them).

Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Thursday October 21, 2021 @12:33PM (#28946992)
Same thing. Everyone uses public stations all the time.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by caf on Thursday October 21, 2021 @05:26PM (#28951009)
They really don't. Pretty much anyone with the ability to charge at home, charges at home for all their day-to-day driving, with stops at charging stations used only for infrequent longer trips.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Thursday October 21, 2021 @06:24PM (#28951556)
Only because they have to. If there was a way to recharge within 3 minutes publically, the home charging solution would be rarely used.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by caf on Thursday October 21, 2021 @06:51PM (#28951799)
Why do you think so? The convenience of taking a few moments to plug in when you park for the night, over taking a specific trip to a charging destination, seems pretty hard to beat (and that's before factoring in that home electricity rates are in general considerably cheaper).
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Thursday October 21, 2021 @07:20PM (#28952022)
In the Northeast, people often use fuel oil delivered to their house for heating. Except that this fuel oil is basically diesel/kerosene, meaning we already had a system of delivery fuel to people's houses. And yet there was never an outcry for home refueling for their cars. It clearly wasn't something that people wanted even when they had it. So it's hard to see why now all of a sudden this is a real selling point.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by caf on Friday October 22, 2021 @07:15AM (#28955819)
Probably because the idea of "you have to be home with the car waiting for the fuel guy to turn up" destroys a lot of the convenience, and the fact that car fuel tanks are more than 15 times smaller than typical heating oil tanks means you'd be paying a lot more overhead.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:07PM (#28958914)
You have a big tank of fuel that can be stored up until you need it. It also takes a few minutes, not the hours you have to wait until a battery is full.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by caf on Saturday October 23, 2021 @08:56AM (#28967944)
I don't see how this follows as a response to the previous comment.

(The time required by home charging is not particularly relevant if it's happening while you're sleeping or the car is otherwise idle, anyway).

Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by caf on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:33PM (#28982144)
To clarify: Considering how popular it is to get other frequently-used consumables home delivered, like food and alcohol, it is on the face of it somewhat surprising that the same is not true of liquid vehicle fuel. My prior comment was suggesting some possible reasons this might be so.

Thinking through it some more, the objection around the vehicle needing to be home at the time the delivery is made can be overcome by having the deliveries made late at night, as long as there was some way to give the delivery driver access to the car's fuel tank. At the end of the day it may just be too inefficient to have liquid fuel delivered weekly in 30-60 litre quantities, the overhead being too great.

Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by jliptzin on Thursday October 21, 2021 @01:57PM (#28948413)
Home charging was one of the primary reasons I bought an EV in the first place, I hate going to gas stations especially when they're out of the way or when I'm not driving through a great area.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Thursday October 21, 2021 @04:41PM (#28950568)
Everyone says this but they still talk about public charging all the time. It's mostly just a rationalization.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by jliptzin on Thursday October 21, 2021 @07:15PM (#28951972)
They do? I've never had a problem the handful of times I needed to charge on the road.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Thursday October 21, 2021 @07:48PM (#28952248)
The point is that they talk about it. Either positively or negative, it means that they're using the public chargers.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by jliptzin on Friday October 22, 2021 @07:46AM (#28956070)
What do you mean by public chargers? Does that include superchargers?
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:07PM (#28958915)
Yes, all of the above.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by jliptzin on Friday October 22, 2021 @08:54PM (#28964617)
I do a lot of driving and still I have only had to use public chargers a handful of times over 2 years. Even if not staying at home I can usually at least plug into a 110v outlet somewhere or I stay at a hotel that has an EV charger.
Re:Tesla Q3 2021 Earnings by Hypx_ on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:20PM (#28965393)
Even a 110V plug still counts as a public charger. The point is that you still care about them. Even if you go out of your way to not think about them, you're still forced to use them from time to time.