Re:Platonism in the Philosophy of Mathematics (2018)
by dvt on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @05:33PM
(#28936981)
> So what is the point of such debate?
This is an incredibly parochial point of view.
Kant's seminal "existence is not a predicate" argument has had a foundational impact after he put the rationalist vs. empiricist debate to rest. In fact, it's extremely deep, arguing that the P in ∃xPx can't be "exists." Modal logicians have tried to come up with more clever ways of circumventing this, e.g. E(t) := ∃x(x=t)—although this isn't entirely non-problematic, either.
For that matter, the question of anything existing is profoundly human, so asking "what is the point" kind of misses the point.
This is an incredibly parochial point of view.
Kant's seminal "existence is not a predicate" argument has had a foundational impact after he put the rationalist vs. empiricist debate to rest. In fact, it's extremely deep, arguing that the P in ∃xPx can't be "exists." Modal logicians have tried to come up with more clever ways of circumventing this, e.g. E(t) := ∃x(x=t)—although this isn't entirely non-problematic, either.
For that matter, the question of anything existing is profoundly human, so asking "what is the point" kind of misses the point.