News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Platonism in the Philosophy of Mathematics (2018) by dvt on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @05:33PM (#28936981)
> So what is the point of such debate?

This is an incredibly parochial point of view.

Kant's seminal "existence is not a predicate" argument has had a foundational impact after he put the rationalist vs. empiricist debate to rest. In fact, it's extremely deep, arguing that the P in ∃xPx can't be "exists." Modal logicians have tried to come up with more clever ways of circumventing this, e.g. E(t) := ∃x(x=t)—although this isn't entirely non-problematic, either.

For that matter, the question of anything existing is profoundly human, so asking "what is the point" kind of misses the point.

Re:Platonism in the Philosophy of Mathematics (2018) by Errancer on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @05:40PM (#28937094)
"This is an incredibly parochial point of view.", why? I don't really see how what you said and what I said connect.