News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by aaomidi on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:45PM (#28935309)
ycombinator actively takes ownership of the means of production by providing loans. Any founder knows how predatory external funding is, but, it is the only choice to get a company up and running.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by infamouscow on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:51PM (#28935395)
A founder with the choice of taking YC money also is free to make the decision not to take YC money. What's the problem besides some abstract argument of moral superiority?
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by andrepd on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:00PM (#28935577)
Yes, indeed if you assume that the current system for allocating capital is good then you conclude that the current system for allocating capital is good. If you apply a bit more critical thinking you can start to question whether the fact that a small proportion of people have a monopoly on the ownership, allocation, and creation of capital, and are therefore able to extract rent from loaning it out without providing any value themselves, whether that is a good thing at all.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by sershe on Thursday October 21, 2021 @10:33AM (#28945029)
The "small monopoly" in this thread is Paul Graham, who created his capital himself.

First-a, he deserves what he has (as far as you can make such a statement in a complex society). He provided some value, got paid for it, he now takes a risk helping others do the same. The only difference between him and me consuming X, providing X+Y value, and using the Y to buy tiny parts of public companies to have some claim on their profits is scale.

First-b, and yes, if someone came and took away my Y for "fairness", I would start working less to just make what I consume. And I mostly /like/ my job, unlike most people.

Second-a, after critically thinking about it, I actually believe it's better for people like him to allocate capital, instead of either some "democratic process", or even worse some semi-elected bureaucrats. I wish we could have people like Bezos, Buffett, Graham, etc. run MANY MORE things (generally speaking, not attached to a particular implementation). We have all of history to indicate who does things better. Second-a-a, even if we were to say "free market is bad in this area, no free market is allowed [e.g. healthcare or housing]" (to be clear, I disagree with that, but let's say we did) I would prefer to install a conventionally-defined-self-made billionaire from another industry to run said area, instead of a govt bureaucracy like we do now.

Third, as others have mentioned you don't have to take his money, you can bootstrap (and then get rich and loan money just like him).

Second-b, combining second-a and third in a more narrow scope, do you think either voters or bureaucrats would fund startups (and, do it better than the likes of VCs)? It has happened, but rarely and almost always in response to an existential threat. Viaweb FAQ says they were financed by angels to the tune of $2m 90ies-dollars. What are the alternative sources of funding you envision in the "fairer" allocation structure for such startups, be it Tesla, Google, or Viaweb, given their success rate?

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by Nasrudith on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:50PM (#28936350)
If it isn't good then what does that make the failed alternatives? While both money and bullshit talk, actual ability takes action and gets results.

Communism is an outright religion - there is no experimentalism, outcomes are preordained, and no results may change the assumptions. The only thinking is telological. If anybody pays X for a product and sells it for X + Y where Y is greater than zero it is automatically exploitation by their conveniently loaded definitions.

1. The idea that loaning it out isn't providing any value in itself is objectively wrong. If it provides no value is ridiculous in even a preindustrial economy - let alone an industrialized one where economies of scale and large capex are why markets wind up dominated by big players.

2. The idea that it is a small monopoly is also objectively wrong - money is fungible and it doesn't matter if you get one million in a loan from one entity or ten thousand ones. Even if we accept the standards of morality "if it is a good thing" is irrelevant a question as asking if it is a good thing that vehicles use electricity or break down fuels to move. Those are the mechanisms by which it works - we don't have an option of movement without expending energy. Similarly if you ask for all loans to be free to avoid "exploitation" there is no reason to lock up the money in delays and put it at risk.

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by andrepd on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @05:07PM (#28936632)
There's so many much misconceptions in the first two paragraphs alone that I don't even know where to start x) I feel it would just be wasted time.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by infamouscow on Thursday October 21, 2021 @01:15AM (#28940575)
If that were true, it shouldn't take much effort to point out a few of them, right?

Your response is typical of psudo-intellectuals called out on their bullshit. It's a lot easier to say "I'm right regardless of the facts" instead of directly addressing the points raised.

Provide a rebuttal or stop with your nonsense.

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by andrepd on Thursday October 21, 2021 @11:00AM (#28945438)
1. Conflating any criticism of the current system of neoliberal capitalism with "ah! then you must prefer to live in north korea!" is a classical tactic of misdirection.

2. "Communism is an outright religion - there is no experimentalism, outcomes are preordained" is a case of en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong. I don't even know what I'm supposed to say to this other than "pick up a book".

3. "If anybody pays X for a product and sells it for X + Y where Y is greater than zero it is automatically exploitation by their conveniently loaded definitions." Again, this is the idea of "communizm" I had when I was 12 or 13. As you can imagine, either everyone who is a socialist or anarchist or left-libertarian or whatever is a complety drooling idiot, or this is a stupid straw-man designed to fool people with zero critical thinking skills.

4. "If it provides no value is ridiculous in even a preindustrial economy - let alone an industrialized one where economies of scale and large capex are why markets wind up dominated by big players." Again, this is circular reasoning: in the current system providing capital is a valuable service, therefore the system is good since in the system the system is good... do you see what I mean? You cannot justify a thing by reasons internal to the thing itself.

5. "Those are the mechanisms by which it works" See above. I'll also add: capitalism (and specifically our current flavour thereof) is not a Law of Nature: it is the result of a very specific course that history took over the past 300 years. Alternatives are possible. Criticism is legitimate. Ambition to improve is a good thing.

Shall I go on? I learned it's not useful to talk with people who are not in good faith from the get go. Why bother?

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by infamouscow on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:14PM (#28935816)
I'm not making a value judgement like you are.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by Nullabillity on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:23PM (#28935961)
There are two ways to interpret your comment. Either 1) "The current system is good, actually", or 2) "This is just how the current system is".

1 is obviously a value judgement. 2 contributes nothing to the discussion.

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by splistud on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:27PM (#28936025)
If, as you mistakenly assert, capital is scarce, then providing capital is a value. You can't have it both ways.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by aaomidi on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:54PM (#28935457)
Think out of the box for a second, is this really the only possible choices we have here? Or are billionaires using and designing the system to create more opportunities to make $$$ at the expense of others work.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by infamouscow on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:08PM (#28935714)
Have you visited IndieHackers.com? They are demonstrating you don't need funding to create amazing things.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by losvedir on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @06:25PM (#28937619)
Thanks for letting me know about this site. I hadn't seen it before! I don't suppose I could beg an invite from you...?
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by infamouscow on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @09:02PM (#28938957)
Unfortunately I don't have any invite codes, but I'm sure another reader on HN could help you out :)
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by splistud on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:30PM (#28936056)
It's not out of the box thinking. The problem is that you want to throw one of the values out of the calculation box. You want billionaires to provide capital because there is 'no other way to get a startup going (paraphrasing)' but you don't want to assign a value to that (as in, the workers are what is creating the value).
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by krona on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:16PM (#28935837)
You're using corporatism to argue against capitalism. They're not the same thing.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by irl_chad on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:52PM (#28935411)
Do you actually think VC money is predatory?

I have a $1m MMR startup that I founded without any external funding - but mostly because I was naive to such structures existing at all. I would have saved years of struggling if I had an initial cash infusion of a few hundred thousand.

Idk about you, but I would trade 10% of my $1m MMR company for more free time during my early 20s.

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by aaomidi on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:53PM (#28935436)
> Do you actually think VC money is predatory?

Yes. But again, not a lot of options to avoid it as you said.

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by encoderer on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:00PM (#28935579)
There are tons of options.

Like for example just build something and start selling it and make money.

That's what I did. Millions others have too. You are on Hacker News, you are probably a hacker, you can just create assets out of thin air!

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by splistud on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:33PM (#28936099)
It is more predatory than simple business lending leading to making enough revenue to justify more private lending leading to forming a small public company. The only reason there is so much VC money in this industry is because there is little revenue in selling user data or eyeballs at small scale.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by StevePerkins on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:57PM (#28935514)
> "takes ownership of the means of production..."

> "Warren Buffett has made his money using ... land ownership and exclusivity ... a human construct"

Well, sheesh... if your starting frame of reference is that "capitalism is stealing by definition", then there's really no further discussion to be had.

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by aaomidi on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:05PM (#28935666)
> then there's really no further discussion to be had.

Why not? Is Capitalism the universal truth or something that we can't touch or change?

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by irl_chad on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:21PM (#28935936)
It’s the default system that will always arise. Even in the USSR, there was a black market.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by ModernMech on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @08:01PM (#28938501)
The concept of markets is not exclusive to capitalism.
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by andrepd on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:05PM (#28935661)
What about your starting point, that appears to be "capitalism is a natural law as inescapable as gravity"? x)
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by encoderer on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:50PM (#28935387)
Slow down, Karl.

I'm a founder. I can tell you, external funding is as generous now as it's ever been, and in my network there are YC alumns (and 2-time alums) that would disagree with your take.

Also, we are in a golden age of bootstrapping, you don't need to raise to get a company up and running.

All this to say: Maybe just possibly capitalism isn't so bad? My dad is the manager of a gas station, and I am the founder of a startup with financial security. Anything really is possible when you work for it.

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by andrepd on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:04PM (#28935648)
> Maybe just possibly capitalism isn't so bad?

Ironically, you know who else thought the exact same thing, lavishing praise on capitalism? Karl Marx. Maybe educate yourself and open your horizons to something outside your narrow views. I have no problem with people being ignorant (nobody knows everything), but it's grating when somebody is proud of it.

> Anything really is possible when you work for it.

Actually nevermind, such naivete is mind-boggling.

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by encoderer on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @04:05PM (#28935675)
Great chat Andre!
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by aaomidi on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:54PM (#28935469)
> Maybe just possibly capitalism isn't so bad

That's the best part, it isn't for a chunk of people. It destroys life for another chunk of people.

So yeah, maybe, to you, it's not bad. To others? It's fucked.

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by infamouscow on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @07:44PM (#28938358)
Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by aaomidi on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @08:40PM (#28938790)
1. I never said anything about communism.

2. Do you consider all the supply chain related deaths, all the prison related deaths, all the civilians killed in America going after oil part of "people killed under capitalism?"

Re:Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair by infamouscow on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @09:18PM (#28939096)
What you're describing is deaths under Crony capitalism.