I think a key point I started making but didn't really conclude is that British comedies stay with me; I can quote them, accidentally fall into their characters like an eccentric myself, enjoy them without re-watching them. Monty Python; Fawlty Towers; Reggie Perrin; The Office; Green Wing; Dad's Army; et alia.
I think the closest I can come to that sort of absent enjoyment with US TV comedy is to imagine April Ludgate's (Parks & Recreation) face in reaction to something.
Maybe it's partly that US comedy veers more visual & slapstick? Certainly not all of it, there's very little in general, I commented on that in a recent thread on Airplane!, but that too is American of course. Though I'm not sure how well Fawlty Towers would work audio-only.
I think part of what you're identifying about first episodes is maybe a difference in style between the US and UK. A lot of UK comedy definitely seems like the characters are pre-baked into the writing and the actor is already mature in the role in the beginning, while in the US it feels like they've left the role a little hollow at first and allow the actors (and future writing) to evolve the role into what it will be. This can make the first episodes feel "off" when you go back to watch them, but I'm not sure it's necessarily a bad way to go if the goal is to find a really good character.
It's also possible that the UK network(s) are amenable to planned out entire seasons while the US networks are more accepting of buying a pilot of a few episodes and seeing where something goes, which would favor some of these approaches in each case.