Re:Simple Linux kernel memory corruption bug can lead to com...
by nyanpasu64 on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @02:35AM
(#28927462)
The problem was that one of two threads locked the wrong lock before accessing a shared resource (when two threads read or write shared memory, both sides must acquire mutexes or it's useless), resulting in a data race.
Rust could prevent this issue by requiring that all non-exclusive accesses to the shared data acquire the mutex (and if you use Mutex<T> which wraps the data, you'll always acquire the right mutex). The & vs. &mut system can model exclusive access ("initialization/destruction functions that have exclusive access to the entire object and can access members without locking"). It doesn't help with RCU vs. refcounted references, or "non-RCU members are exclusively owned by thread performing teardown" or "RCU callback pending, non-RCU members are uninitialized" or "exclusive access to RCU-protected members granted to thread performing teardown, other members are uninitialized". And Rust is worse than C at working with uninitialized memory (Rust not using the same type for initialized vs. uninitialized memory/references is a feature, but uninitialized memory references are too awkward IMO).
Rust could prevent this issue by requiring that all non-exclusive accesses to the shared data acquire the mutex (and if you use Mutex<T> which wraps the data, you'll always acquire the right mutex). The & vs. &mut system can model exclusive access ("initialization/destruction functions that have exclusive access to the entire object and can access members without locking"). It doesn't help with RCU vs. refcounted references, or "non-RCU members are exclusively owned by thread performing teardown" or "RCU callback pending, non-RCU members are uninitialized" or "exclusive access to RCU-protected members granted to thread performing teardown, other members are uninitialized". And Rust is worse than C at working with uninitialized memory (Rust not using the same type for initialized vs. uninitialized memory/references is a feature, but uninitialized memory references are too awkward IMO).