IDK a whole lot about IPFS though. Maybe it was the metadata resolving / DHT lookup or whatever that was super slow. BitTorrent latency was always pretty high, but it didn't matter because throughput was also high
Paying for pinning sounds like something that could work but it would introduce some of the same problems that the real web suffers from back into IPFS. The idea "a web for the people, by the people" becomes problematic when you start paying people to make your content more accessible.
The thing I liked about the idea of IPFS pinning is that you are paying per byte stored, v.s. per byte accessed, as long as the p2p sharing works. I.e. hosting-via-pinning a website only you read would cost the same as hosting a website that the whole internet reads.
From what I could tell the performance issue was mostly located in the networking itself, getting the client to resolve the content on the right server. That's something that could be improved through all kinds of algorithms without breaking compatibility or functionality, so there's hope.
I agree that pinning comes with some interesting ways to monetize hosting without the need for targeted advertising that the web seems to have these days. Small projects like blogs, webcomics and animations could be entirely hosted and supported by the communities around a work, while right now giant data brokers need to step in and host everything for "free".
"It stays in the cache as long as it stays in the cache"
??? What on earth does this mean?
This is opposed to long-term caches like Cloudflare's that'll cache the contents of your website regardless of how many requests come in. Cloudflare will happily just refresh the contents of your website even if nobody has been to your website for weeks, and quickly serve it up when it's needed.
The downside of this approach is that it only works with popular nodes and you'd be back to the old, centralised internet architecture for all real use cases.
I don't think you can accurately gauge what is and isn't popular in a P2P network like IPFS. You never have a view of the entire network, after all.
There's also the problem of running such a system. Who pays for the system's upkeep and do we trust them? If we'd use Cloudflare's excellent features, who says Cloudflare won't intentionally uncache a post criticising their centralisation of the internet, forcing the views they disagree with to the slow net while the views they agree with get served blazingly fast.
I don't think such a system would work well if we intend to keep the decentralised nature of IPFS alive. Explicit caching leads to centralization, that's the exact reason caching works.
Instead, the entire network needs a performance boost. I don't know where the performance challenges in IPFS lie, but I'm sure there's ways to improve the system. Getting more people to run and use IPFS would obviously work, but then you'd still only be caching only popular content.
Edit: actually, I don't really want to see caching happen through popularity of the service either, because as it stands IPFS essentially shares your entire browsing history with the world by either requesting documents in plain text or even caching the documents you've just read. I wonder if that IPFS-through-Tor section on their website ever got filled in, because the last few times I've checked that was just a placeholder in their documentation.