I still read Gruber everyday- he has a lot of interesting things to say about technology in general and Apple in particular. But it is increasingly hard to take him seriously about any story related to Apple's anti-android litigation, because he seems to have abandoned any attempt to present the situation fairly, to the point where he has really become a rather naked shill for Apple.
I am typing this on an iPad 2. I love my iPad 2. I tried a great number of tablets prior to purchasing it, and I genuinely find it to be the superior product, and by a long shot. I am even sympathetic to Apple's claims in this case, as I do think the resemblance between the Galaxy and the iPad to be more than simple coincidence. But it seems pretty clear to me that this is about much more (or should be about much more) than one "doctored" photo, and I am absolutely sure that Gruber knows it.
The thing is, I don't think he cares, because it seems as if he's completely abandoned even the pretense of presenting a just and fair picture of any of Apple's recent patent litigation.
http://daringfireball.net/feeds/sponsors/
With ads making him $6000 a week, I don't blame him. He is telling people what they want to hear and the ads reach people they're trying to reach. He gets invited to Apple events thanks to him being the unofficial de-facto Apple PR and he can't risk hurting that. There's no incentive for him to be objective, in fact it is in his interest to lay the spin on thick.
Get with the program!
Gruber claims that "The dispute here is over one image" [1], but I don't think that's accurate. Almost all of the images in the document have been squeezed in manners that make the devices look more similar.
- Many of the images are taken at an extreme angle which, while looking very nice, doesn't let you get a good look at the device (e.g. pp. 26, 32, 38)
- They play pretty free and loose with distorting the aspect ratios of their images. See a decidedly square-looking Tab on pp. 26, 35 and a freakishly elongated iPad on pp. 27, 36.
- pp. 39 takes the cake for "how can we fudge things to make it look like they're the same size"
In fact, far from being "over one image", it seems that the majority of the images have has their aspect ratios distorted in order to make the devices seem more similar, and the remainder have been shot at angles that deliberately hide dissimilarities.
I would argue that the aspect ratio of the Tab is one of its most distinctive features (I don't like it, but it is distinctive...). It's the first thing you notice when you pick one up. Not surprising that Apple is trying to downplay this difference.
[1] http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/08/15/apple-samsung-im...