News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @01:13PM (#28880206)
> The problem with Facebook/Amazon/Google is that they have a monopoly on a specific information network, for Facebook the social graph, internet discoverability for Google, and online shopping for Amazon.

None of these things are a natural monopoly.

Facebook only stays relevant by buying its competitors. You don't even need to break them up, just disable acquisitions. Then Instagram would be separate, WhatsApp would be separate. You don't even have to break them apart, just wait for the next one and don't let them buy it.

Google is the biggest search engine but search isn't a natural monopoly. Their dominant position comes from all the vertical integration. Google owns YouTube and YouTube is featured prominently in Google Search results. To get Android/Google Play, OEMs have to use Google as their default search engine. To fix this you don't have to regulate the search results, just separate the search engine from the other companies, and stop allowing them to buy competing ad networks.

Amazon doesn't really even have a dominant market position. They're not a railroad, they're Internet Walmart. They're just the biggest player in a highly competitive market. They have no capacity to significantly raise prices or people would immediately switch to any of their hundreds of competitors. Most of the complaints are from competitors butthurt that Amazon is keeping everyone's margins slim -- but that's what they're supposed to be doing.

A railroad is a natural monopoly. You can't really break up a natural monopoly, so you have to regulate it, which is terrible.

None of this tech stuff is like that. The problems here come from consolidation through mergers and vertical integration. They're unnatural monopolies with clear lines across which they can be broken up without long-term regulation. Just stop letting them buy their competitors.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by throwaway09223 on Friday October 15, 2021 @01:47PM (#28880682)
Google isn't primarily a search engine. By revenue they're primarily an ad network.

Ad networks naturally form monopolies. Ad matching algorithms can make better matches (more revenue per click and more desirable product for advertisers) the more ad campaigns they have to select from and the more display properties they have to publish ads to. It's a market extremely prone to winner-takes-all.

I say this as someone who worked internally on an ad system which used to be one of Google's primary competitors. I specifically worked on projects intended to address these runaway network effects. It wasn't possible and the company exited the business (they actually tried to be a customer of google's because it'd be more profitable to just show their ads, but this was blocked on antitrust grounds ...)

The monopolistic aspects of these entities aren't necessarily the customer facing products they market to the masses.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:40PM (#28881395)
Ad networks don't naturally form monopolies. That's why Google had to buy the other ones. Anything will form a monopoly if you let every company in the industry merge.

Just because something has a network effect doesn't make it a natural monopoly. The network effect means the network may need a minimum size in order to be viable, but that doesn't mean there can't be a dozen competing networks of that size that are all viable.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by throwaway09223 on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:11PM (#28881833)
It does, because the increased efficiency means ads are more profitable on the larger platforms. Bigger matching pools mean better conversion rates.

Why would you spend more money to buy a less-well performing ad?

Why would you display a less well paying ad on your web property?

If you're doing search ads, you cannot fund the megawatts of infrastructure to keep pace with google if you're working with smaller margins. This is not theoretical - adwords/search has destroyed almost all of the competition, save those who have other ways of funding themselves.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:24PM (#28883283)
> Bigger matching pools mean better conversion rates.

So the smaller networks would make less money than Google. Less money than Google isn't the same as less money than is necessary to run servers.

And servers get cheaper as time goes on. The number of "megawatts" you need to serve a given number of ads is exponentially decreasing over time.

> This is not theoretical - adwords/search has destroyed almost all of the competition, save those who have other ways of funding themselves.

You can't ignore the companies they bought out when you say the others went out of business. They don't have any reason to buy a competitor that was just going to fail anyway, and they empirically have bought several competitors.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by throwaway09223 on Saturday October 16, 2021 @11:40AM (#28888611)
No, this isn't true. The hardware necessary to run a competitive search engine increases over time on a massive scale because the size of the internet grows faster than the price of hardware can fall.

This is why search engines have consolidated into Google and Bing. It is not currently possible to create a search engine.

> The number of "megawatts" you need to serve a given number of ads is exponentially decreasing over time.

This is completely backwards. This is not theoretical, this is a fact. Please understand that I spent half a decade building bigger and bigger datacenters because the rate of infrastructure expansion to keep pace with growth is absolutely massive.

> You can't ignore the companies they bought out when you say the others went out of business.

They did not buy out their primary competitor. I have an insider view here and while I can't share the details I can say that you really have no idea what you're talking about.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by Apes on Friday October 15, 2021 @01:20PM (#28880286)
Amazon does leverage their position as market maker to undercut competition with anti-competitive practices though. They run data analytics to figure out what goods are the most profitable, then launch competing products and promote their own over the originals in their listings. Their monopoly gives them the ability to take over nearly any market they want at any time, with no consequences.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:53PM (#28881576)
> They run data analytics to figure out what goods are the most profitable, then launch competing products and promote their own over the originals in their listings.

Figuring out which products have high margins and entering those markets is an increase in competition.

Promoting their own listings is only a problem if the competitors can't reach those customers in any other reasonable way, which isn't the case because there are many other online retailers and it's quite feasible for a medium sized competitor to sell directly to the customer on their own website.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by wilburTheDog on Friday October 15, 2021 @01:36PM (#28880501)
>Just stop letting them buy their competitors.

And how would you stop them from simply replacing their competitors? From the article "Budding companies that resist being acquired are pruned through flagrant copying." Would you pass a law that said Facebook can't expand their business to do anything a competitor is doing? I can't see how that would fly.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:50PM (#28881522)
Copying doesn't really work. WhatsApp was big before Facebook bought them. Just because you copy some feature they had doesn't mean anybody is going to move back. Having the feature first makes you better. Having the feature second only makes you the same.

And the challenger has an advantage against a conglomerated incumbent because they can add features that reduce profits in ancillary markets the challenger isn't in. The incumbent won't want to copy that and cannibalize their other market, but the users want that feature so the challenger gains market share.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by jensensbutton on Friday October 15, 2021 @10:52PM (#28885153)
> And how would you stop them from simply replacing their competitors?

Competent competitors will do that naturally. See TikTok vs Reels.