News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by matthewdgreen on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:01AM (#28864321)
I see a number of comments below hailing this as a good thing, one that will benefit students. These folks look at Universities as just another company and think this is normal. It is not. It is a terrible mistake and the GA system (and its students, and society) will be worse off for it.

The notion of tenure wasn't developed to protect dead wood. It came about because historically it was often difficult to distinguish "fired for cause" from "fired for speaking out in ways that irritate the powers that be." The ability to fire people for cause is appropriate to businesses and startups, and even there we routinely hear about controversies where "for cause" is blurred together with "saying things that leadership didn't like." The tenure system was explicitly designed to prevent that, and yes, the "cost" of that system is that some dead wood will slip by -- but this has always been an acceptable cost. Our society relies on having a pool of people who cannot be easily silenced by their employers. We will suffer when those guarantees are weakened.

On a personal note: I'm a tenured CS professor and make less than half (often significantly less) than what my colleagues in industry make, for a job that often requires longer hours and a lot of travel. I also have had some experience with having my speech restricted by the administration [1] under the guise of "violations of University policy". As a tenured faculty member I stay because there is no other job where I can speak about anything I want, even if sometimes I say dumb things. My colleagues in industry can't do this -- some of them tell me they are scared to even "like" Tweets that criticize their employer. That's messed up.

To those folks who don't care about these broader arguments and think this decision is reasonable, that it "will improve faculty performance," even there you're wrong. If GA becomes the state that doesn't have tenure, all the best faculty will go to other states and/or to industry. Every state university already struggles to get top talent, and now GA has given themselves a huge hiring disadvantage. Whatever "productivity" benefits you might get from greater faculty control are going to be hugely outweighed by the fallout from this stupid (and obviously political) decision. The board of regents knows this, and they don't care.

[1] https://www.cnet.com/tech/services-and-software/johns-hopkin...

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by kxyvr on Thursday October 14, 2021 @11:12AM (#28865403)
Piggybacking the comment about Georgia becoming less attractive and competitive for good faculty, in 2015 Wisconsin significantly weakened the tenure system as well. I was curious about the affect of that decision and found this recently published paper:

https://peer.asee.org/impacts-of-governmental-policy-actions...

As a note, Wisconsin simultaneously weakened tenure and cut the university budget, which makes it difficult to distinguish the affect of each change. Nevertheless, the net result was fewer faculty and increased class size. Personally, I agree with your sentiment. This makes Georgia far less attractive for good faculty and those with options will go elsewhere.

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by geodel on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:57AM (#28865150)
I see little differently here.

With rare exceptions University professor hardly criticize things that make university money.

General employees criticizing employer are seen as hypocrite when they seem just fine getting their share of money earned by employer's bad behavior.

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by steelframe on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:06AM (#28864384)
I didn't read your username at first, and about 3/4 of the way through I asked myself, "Wait, is this Matthew Green?"

Just letting you know from here on out you'll never be to pull off a nom-de-plume.

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by jbrwn on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:28AM (#28864738)
I am inclined to agree with you but I am also somewhat conflicted due to recent events at my alma mater. It was just revealed that a tenured CS professor is the author of a hate filled blog that disparages women, lgbtq+, and minorities [1]. Ostensibly this guy is "protected" due to his tenure status. I am not sure this is really good for anyone.

[1] http://www.montanakaimin.com/news/computer-science-professor...

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by bsder on Saturday October 16, 2021 @02:13AM (#28885924)
One thing you have to remember is that tenure protects teachers against the religious activists. The religious activists are ALWAYS more motivated and numerous than any defense that teachers can mount.

This is continuous and everlasting. Things like "critical race theory" and its ilk are the current bugaboos. But the "Theory of Evolution" was there in the past. Talking about the documented historical evils that various religions promulgated always sets off the nitwits. Even teaching Canterbury Tales in English and pointing out that the priest has symptoms of syphilis will tend to rile up the local frocks.

The problem is that in 1965 talking about the equality of women and minorities was "controversial" enough that it needed to be protected by tenure. And the college campuses were definitely at the epicenter of the equality movements.

Right now, I suspect that talking about abortion needs to be protected by tenure.

I'm not sure what the right answer is, but destroying tenure is, I suspect, going to do far more damage than good--especially for progressive causes.

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by JasonFruit on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:35AM (#28864840)
I think that politically correct ideas about one of those groups are both illogical and harmful to society. Some might find my views repugnant and wrongly describe them as "hate-filled". Does that mean I shouldn't be able to hold a job, or that to do so I should have to hide my opinions and express them only surreptitiously? If not, your argument against tenure doesn't hold. If so, I'd love to hear more about your reasoning.
Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by jbrwn on Thursday October 14, 2021 @01:25PM (#28867226)
> Does that mean I shouldn't be able to hold a job, or that to do so I should have to hide my opinions and express them only surreptitiously?

You should, and are, free to express those opinions but bigotry is not a protected class. Your employer should be free to fire you if it doesn't like what you are saying.

What value does tenure provide in this scenario? His blog is not related to CS or academia. He is doing harm to the reputation of the university and CS department.

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by JasonFruit on Thursday October 14, 2021 @02:42PM (#28868228)
I don't agree that he's "doing harm to the reputation of the university and CS department." I notice that it's especially with regard to universities that this argument arises. If he were working at Cost Cutters, or Copps Foods, or State Farm, no one would think that his employer was acting wrongly in employing him. There is nothing about a university that makes employing someone with his opinions do more reputational harm. On the contrary, a university has more reason to tolerate his divergent views, because it is directly concerned with intellectual freedom and free inquiry, which often leads people to investigate and even advocate for positions that are incorrect and even immoral (which, I agree, a cursory look at his website suggests his are). That's what tenure provides in this scenario: protection for intellectual freedom, even when free inquiry carries a professor into areas that are disapproved of in polite society.
Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by jbrwn on Thursday October 14, 2021 @04:43PM (#28869811)
> I don't agree that he's "doing harm to the reputation of the university and CS department."

Well thats where we disagree i guess. When people google University of Montana computer science and see the dozens of articles that pop up about this guy they are not going to think oh yay this school is a champion of intellectual freedom. They are going to see a tenured professor propping up the worst of the worst CS stereotypes and software engineering bro culture.

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by ethbr0 on Thursday October 14, 2021 @11:22AM (#28865557)
It's a fair point. One of the biggest pros in favor of unpopular freedom of speech is preventing revolution via the airing and discussion of suppressed views.

In a college environment is probably the most socially safe (i.e. distinct from propagandizing) and productive (i.e. more likely to be intellectually examined) environments for them.

So if they exist anywhere, and I subscribe to the idea that unpopular things need to be speakable somewhere, then college is a good place.

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by boringg on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:30AM (#28864771)
Sample size of one shouldn't change your perspective on a whole class of people. There are bad actors in every group - and, while it is shameful his deeds, you can't castigate a whole class of people.
Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by ghaff on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:54AM (#28865097)
I'm also not sure extreme cases form a good argument anyway. Tenure isn't a blanket "Get out of jail free" card no matter what the behavior or the offense.
Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by matthewdgreen on Thursday October 14, 2021 @11:20AM (#28865525)
Sometimes the cost of open and unrestricted speech is that people will use it to say ugly things. This is another part of the tradeoff and I think it's still a good one.
Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by justin66 on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:37AM (#28864876)
A tenured faculty member can still be fired for cause. I wouldn't assume that guy's job is safe.
Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by Glyptodon on Thursday October 14, 2021 @11:31AM (#28865686)
Usually after multiple incidents, warnings, rehabilitation plans, and all kinds of chances nobody else gets.
Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by Glyptodon on Thursday October 14, 2021 @11:27AM (#28865633)
The other shoe is tenured faculty get their abusive research transgressions smoothed over and covered up by their institutions because firing is too much trouble.

Improperly consent human research subjects? Abuse children? Abuse students? Hire an unqualified fitness instructor FWB to oversee research data? Have to return a multimillion grant?

Just give said students free tuition and go back to making performative "woke" press releases about the abuser like it never happened.

Of course in states like Georgia they probably don't really care about that kind of thing either, so much as weeding out "liberals" or something.

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by tiahura on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:09AM (#28864434)
“Our society relies on having a pool of people who cannot be easily silenced by their employers.”

Those people are not tenured college professors.

Re:Georgia’s University System Takes On Tenure by mikojan on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:17AM (#28864558)
Exactly. They're billionaires.