I'm sure he's a great person. I'm not speaking against his character, just explaining why hackers would be upset about this.
Re:Jonathan's Card Experiments And Outcomes
by gruseom on Sunday August 14, 2011 @01:28PM
(#2884016)
You did speak against his character. You said he tried to destroy a community. That is not the action of a "great person".
You began from the assumption that Sam is not one of us, the "highly community-driven" hackers. That's factually wrong. He's practically a prototype of the community-minded hackerspace type which you extol.
I don't agree with you that people are upset because they care about communities. A readier explanation is just garden-variety sanctimony. (I'm not referring to your comment here, but others.)
My 2ยข is that Sam seems to process social norms in an unconventional way and it occasionally gets him into a pickle. It also leads to good things. More good than bad, I'd bet.