News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by IlliOnato on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:07PM (#28834528)
Maybe I am not getting it, but to me this long article is about something rather simple: some people got popular on a platform, then the platform was banned, and they cannot easily re-create their following on other similar platforms available.

A similar problem about the platforms themselves: the article mentions that a number of local Indian TikTok-lookalike platforms have been created, but none of them was able to get even a fraction of TikTok popularity.

That said, I was pleased to learn about Savitri and Sanatan Mahto, and enjoyed a few of their videos (on Youtube, ironically).

Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by sgpl on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:59PM (#28834788)
I think the article's trying to convey that instagram has a more curated look and so by algo-design/human-design doesn't reward videos/reels that are shot on poor resolution phones and those that don't directly follow their guidelines for being promoted - these can be barriers for folks from marginalized communities and folks that have poor access to resources.

Tiktok on the other hand promoted your video to other users on the platform regardless of these 'requirements' and as a result those from poor/marginalized communities had the opportunity go viral and gain followers as well - without investment in the polish necessary to gain the same visibility on instagram. This polish could be in the form of better phones(cameras), better clothing or better backgrounds/scenes.

Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by bobthepanda on Monday October 11, 2021 @10:58PM (#28835594)
Eh, TikTok got a lot of heat for telling its moderators to downrank fat people, disabled people, and queer people, so this is not by any means one being better than the other. https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/2/20991843/tiktok-bytedance...
Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by Jensson on Monday October 11, 2021 @11:20PM (#28835712)
They weren't downranked, just ensured they didn't spread too much. I wouldn't be surprised if that is how all those marginalized communities started to love TikTok, since it created all these pockets of positivity instead of spreading the same videos to everywhere and everyone where they start to face more scrutiny and downvotes. Downranked would mean that it would have a hard time everywhere even locally within their communities, but that isn't what happened.

I think they used that concept as a basis for their algorithms later, and just changing the recommendation algorithms changes the feel of the entire platform.

Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by im3w1l on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @01:26AM (#28836384)
There are a lot more poor straight people than there are rich gay people. So tiktok may have been better for most people.
Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by KennyBlanken on Monday October 11, 2021 @09:03PM (#28834811)
It's hard to re-create your following when the new platform goes out of its way to exclude you during its launch (Reels was launched in India days after tiktok was banned), heavily promoting upper caste creators. It's sort of like CEOs who got where they were because of their social networks from private schools and prestigious colleges - and seed money from daddy.

> But rather than court the same creators who had driven the Chinese company’s success, Facebook, Reels’ owner, kick-started its launch campaign by courting a set of influencers from upper-class backgrounds, including Komal Pandey, Kusha Kapila, and Ammy Virk: “A catalog of aspiring lifestyle [examples] for middle-class and upper-middle-class Indians,” was how Dr. Rahul Advani, a research fellow at the University College London, described the launch to Rest of World.

Facebook didn't know about popular tiktokers like the Mahtos, didn't care, or knew full well and specifically wanted to cater "rich lifestyle" content because it's better for selling ads, especially ads for expensive, high-profit-margin stuff.

Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by kumarvvr on Monday October 11, 2021 @10:14PM (#28835333)
You seem to be conflating rich lifestyle with castes.

Sure, there are many wealthy individuals whobare from upper castes.

There are also equally wealthy people from castes across the spectrum.

Influencers are basically rich, urban, 90s gen people. Some of them are from upper castes, some are not.

Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by changchuming on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:24AM (#28836667)
Is it not true that majority of rich people are upper caste though?
Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by gremloni on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:50AM (#28836822)
It depends, merchants are pretty rich and wouldn’t be considered upper caste.
Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by dartharva on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @03:23AM (#28836992)
You are mistaking caste for class. They are not the same. And Facebook and Instagram don't individually go around skimming every reel and asking people to be on their platform and denying others; it's open to all. Instagram Reels just puts video quality as a factor in recommending videos in people's feed, and it just so happens that the less privileged creators don't often manage to rise to those guidelines but those with better phones (with high-quality cameras) and internet do.

>specifically wanted to cater "rich lifestyle" content because it's better for selling ads, especially ads for expensive, high-profit-margin stuff

They don't have to choose between rich and poor audiences for ads. They have more than enough resources to push targeted ads to all kinds of demographics. They have no pragmatic advantage in filtering content for "lifestyle", since every individual user anyway has his own customized feed attuned to his interests. Even if they wanted to only cater to the rich, they won't gain much by cutting down on "poor" content that won't show up on their feed anyway.

Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by webmobdev on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:00AM (#28839100)
> You are mistaking caste for class. They are not the same.

While foreigners may confuse between caste and class, everyone in India knows that there is a high co-relation between caste and class (mobility), and that invariably higher castes are higher on the class hierarchy, among Hindus (the majority population in India). The rigidness of the caste hierarchy that prevented mobility in it (rising up in the caste), has had a modern spillover effect on India's class system too. Many caste supremacist believe that class equality is an attack on the caste system, and thus use this reasoning as a basis to attack the economic and consumerist aspirations of the lower caste.

E.g. Incidents of attack by upper castes on lower caste Hindus when they try to imitate Bollywood types wedding to highlight their better social status:

> “They told us that we had to take birth as upper caste people if we wanted to ride a horse. I pleaded with them that Aakash is an orphan and they allow the marriage procession to pass off peacefully, but they did not budge from their stand,” Khema told Gadh police in the complaint.

Source: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/rajkot/dalit-groom-...

There are many other such examples, where a lower caste is prevented from enjoying the benefits his economic class can afford him, by his castiest upper caste brethren.

Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by dartharva on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:46AM (#28839574)
You're divulging into a different area altogether. It's apparent the person I replied to genuinely wanted to refer to the overall less privileged demographic in his post in the context of Reels and its creators, not specifically to caste.

And they are not the same, however close and correlated you may feel they are.

Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by webmobdev on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @01:27PM (#28854950)
I was pointing out why it is so easy to confuse caste and class. You are thinking of the theory of caste system as per the religious texts, while I am talking about how it practically exists in India - it is an undeniable fact that the large majority of the poor in India are from the lower caste among Hindus, while those of the middle and upper class are majorly from the Hindu upper caste. While they are not the same, the actual incidents of class discrimination show how caste and class are unfortunately tied together in India, simply because caste supremacist (wrongly) believe class mobility upsets the legitimacy of the caste system in modern India. For them, the social aspiration of a lower caste to accumulate wealth and increase their social status, somehow de-legitimizes their own caste status in the rigidly enforced system where caste mobility is no longer practiced by today's Hindus.
Re:Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India by geodel on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:45PM (#28834711)
I mean you are right. Instagram in India (maybe many more places?) has an upscale, fashionable image to it and thronged by celebrities and wannabes. TikTok was platform for subaltern voices so to speak.

So all in all one does not have to be slick fuck to be on TikTok and thats reason of popularity.