News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China blocks Wikimedia from entering World Intellectual P... by aww_dang on Sunday October 10, 2021 @02:49PM (#28820943)
Individuals are not the collective. Not only is it inaccurate as a generalization, but it personifies the collective. A nation state is an abstract concept. Politicians and leaders act. Individuals may agree or disagree. Abstractions have no agency.

This is most apparent for me in the false narrative of, "China lifted a billion people out of poverty".

Unpack that one. This advancement is relative to a largely agrarian society which was then subjected to the Great Leap Forward. Loosening your grip on the victim's neck isn't the same as performing the Heimlich maneuver.

China, the nation advanced economically. Business people worked together to develop an economy. These individuals are the real heroes, not the state. They prevailed despite government regulations, corruption and central planning. Going back to the propaganda narrative, how much better off would the people of China be if they were not under the yoke of the CCP?

From there it is not only easy to see how this narrative is inaccurate, but a toxic mistruth in service of authoritarians. The distinction is important.

https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2012-mapping-chinas-red-n...

Re:China blocks Wikimedia from entering World Intellectual P... by Supermancho on Sunday October 10, 2021 @05:23PM (#28822119)
> Individuals are not the collective. Not only is it inaccurate as a generalization, but it personifies the collective. A nation state is an abstract concept.

A nation state (which is a political organization) is the way that populations interact on the political stage. A nation state presents representatives which uniformly have a manner of control over the population and the forces (eg economic and/or social and/or military) that population can wield. So this "abstract concept" is not relevant in any way to the discussion. China is whatever the CCP says it is, because they can do all the things a nation state might want to do (imprison, slaughter, wage war, nationalize industry, etc).

> This is most apparent for me in the false narrative of, "China lifted a billion people out of poverty".

It's a misrepresentation of history by omission, but it's not false by any stretch. I don't think it's impressive given the historical context, but all sorts of governments use information without context as slogans. I'm not surprised the slogan is so limited. It lifted multiple billions out of poverty by putting them in the ground.

> China, the nation advanced economically. Business people worked together to develop an economy. These individuals are the real heroes, not the state.

They aren't China. They operate there at the CCPs whims. I am confident these individuals operate there because the CCP allows it and doesn't want what they have (yet).

> Going back to the propaganda narrative, how much better off would the people of China be if they were not under the yoke of the CCP?

We are talking about the China of today. Telling someone to make a distinction because you want to discuss about China's future or even alternate past is a derail. GL with whatever.

Re:China blocks Wikimedia from entering World Intellectual P... by int_19h on Sunday October 10, 2021 @06:00PM (#28822371)
A nation-state is not the way that populations interact on the political stage, but rather the way the elites that rule those populations do. You're correct in that the elites are who defines what the "nation-state of China" is, but that doesn't mean that they speak for the "people of China".

(It should be noted that this also goes for the vast majority of nation-states.)