Re:The latest campus cancellation is different
by SiempreViernes on Sunday October 10, 2021 @09:22AM
(#28818214)
Popularity absolutely does not impact the logical correctness of an argument: an argument is true by virtue of its own structure, if you say popularity somehow affects its correctness you've basically jettisoned logic in favour of subjective opinion.
At best popularity serves as a useful heuristic for when you don't have the means to carefully confirm the correctness yourself.
(There is a fairly uninteresting special case where the popularity of something comes in to the argument as a factual statement about the world.)
Re:The latest campus cancellation is different
by bananasbandanas on Sunday October 10, 2021 @11:51AM
(#28819335)
I think you are conflating popularity of an argument with popularity as part of an argument. For the former, it's easy to agree that it does not affect the correctness of the argument. But in the articles case, popularity is part of the argument: That it is especially worrying the speaker is uninvited for an opinion which is held by a majority of people, i.e is popular.
Another example of this would be if we were having an argument about what music to play at some event we are hosting. I might well use the popularity of some songs as an argument.
Re:The latest campus cancellation is different
by civilized on Sunday October 10, 2021 @09:35AM
(#28818296)
Is it so surprising that useful heuristics might be used in lieu of careful thinking for a short mass media essay?
Re:The latest campus cancellation is different
by SiempreViernes on Sunday October 10, 2021 @09:48AM
(#28818382)
No, but something being expected is something else that is not inherently tied to the correctness of an argument.
As a concrete example: wikipedia has a long list of common but incorrect beliefs, all of which one should not be surprised to hear being said but will remain incorrect regardless.
Re:The latest campus cancellation is different
by poetaster on Sunday October 10, 2021 @01:51PM
(#28820456)
The author clearly states that Abott's position was not relevant to the talk he was to present. Wether his position on admittance us congruent with progress in client science has yet to be adressed.
His argument is strengthened by, but doesn’t rely on, that fact.