Re:San Francisco Subway Muzzles Cell Service During Protest
by sehugg on Friday August 12, 2011 @10:33PM
(#2880061)
I don't know that the technical details factor into this -- BART admitted that their intent was to prevent speech and to interfere with communications, therefore it's possible they ran afoul of the First Amendment and/or the FCC. I don't know that we'll find the answer unless someone takes it to trial.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:San Francisco Subway Muzzles Cell Service During Protest
by blantonl on Friday August 12, 2011 @11:29PM
(#2880155)
I'm not condoning what BART did, I think it was wrong.
But, if you decided to use HN to organize a response to an issue and HN deleted your posts, that doesn't make HN's actions a First Amendment issue. The First Amendment does not apply for private institutions that you choose to participate on.
Re:San Francisco Subway Muzzles Cell Service During Protest
by yummyfajitas on Friday August 12, 2011 @11:36PM
(#2880163)
BART is a government agency, not a private institution.
Re:San Francisco Subway Muzzles Cell Service During Protest
by joeguilmette on Friday August 12, 2011 @11:39PM
(#2880167)
HN has a TOS and is a private institution. Further, HN is not part of our public telecom infrastructure - ie if I'm being stabbed during the protest they were trying to thwart, I wouldn't use HN to call an ambulance.
BART shutting down cell service is irresponsible, deplorable and something we're going to see more and more as the first world descends into the kind of place we all see it becoming.