News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why isn't Usenet used anymore? by kazinator on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:11PM (#28793872)
Firstly, yes, there is something broken about it: Google Groups. Any new user becoming interested in Usenet will more likely than not end up in that quagmire, which will likely kill their appetite for Usenet rather quick.

But Google Groups is probably the only thing that could handle a large scale influx of users.

There simply aren't that many free Usenet servers.

If Usenet were to suddenly explode in popularity for some reason, those users not wanting to put up with Google Groups would probably overwhelm the small number of free NNTP servers.

Speaking of servers, what (almost) killed Usenet was ISP's shutting down their NNTP servers. It used to be that every major ISP ran an NNTP server you could connect to, similarly to how they give you an e-mail server. This service was obviously not free; it was part of the service package, though, so it looked free.

A big reason they stopped doing that was that most of the NNTP volume came to consist of copyright-infringing binaries.

People are now used to actually free discussion forums like Reddit; any resurgence of Usenet will have to use free servers (and your ISP won't provide a free-looking one any more). Too few users are willing to pay for Usenet access; a Usenet resurgence based on paying users connecting to servers cannot happen.

There is little economic incentive for anyone to provide a free Usenet server, because there is no revenue. You cannot collect any accurate personal information, and you cannot serve advertising. I suppose NNTP could be hacked to insert advertising into articles. These ads would likely be ineffective in their limited format, and face a backlash. Still, that's an idea. For instance, the non-paying users of an NNTP server might not get to see the original signatures of articles; the server would replace it with its own, containing an ad. Moreover, when posting, non-paying users would have their outgoing signature replaced by an ad. Paying users would see original signatures and get to send their own.

Before BitTorrent, people posted binaries as multi-part MIME or uuencode jobs to Usenet, believe it or not, using multiple articles. The clients still support automatic decoding of binaries from multiple posts.

It would be nice for Usenet to come back without the alt.binaries.* cruft that is not so useful today anyway.

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't Usenet used anymore? by u801e on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:42AM (#28795816)
> what (almost) killed Usenet was ISP's shutting down their NNTP servers. It used to be that every major ISP ran an NNTP server you could connect to

> [...]

> A big reason they stopped doing that was that most of the NNTP volume came to consist of copyright-infringing binaries.

Another reason was the deal that Andrew Cuomo (when he was the attorney general of New York) made with a number of major ISPs to prevent dissemination of child pornography. That lead to a lot of them discontinuing their Usenet service.

> There is little economic incentive for anyone to provide a free Usenet server, because there is no revenue.

It could be done using a web portal like they do for free email service, but it would be cumbersome to use.

> Before BitTorrent, people posted binaries as multi-part MIME or uuencode jobs to Usenet, believe it or not, using multiple articles.

They still do, but they use a more efficient encoding scheme called yEnc, which only has a few percent overhead in terms of attachment size, unlike base64 which has a 33% overhead.

> It would be nice for Usenet to come back without the alt.binaries.* cruft

I've always wondered why feeds couldn't be configured to exclude alt.binaries.*. Was it due to peering arrangements with other servers?

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't Usenet used anymore? by jimmyvalmer on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:56PM (#28794316)
Google Groups effectively salvaged what was left of Usenet, so saying they broke Usenet is rather uncharitable.

Gen Z doesn't even use email, so "any new user becoming interested in Usenet" seems unlikely.

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't Usenet used anymore? by kazinator on Thursday October 07, 2021 @09:49PM (#28794762)
You rightfully point to the social problem. Since around the approximate start of the Usenet shakedown, kids were born who are now in college. So ...