Re:Dutch watchdog finds Apple App Store payment rules anti-c...
by avianlyric on Thursday October 07, 2021 @11:07AM
(#28787302)
In the court’s defence, these documents are rarely sealed forever. Usually they become public after the ruling has been made.
If an appeal is being made, and current decision being temporary suspended, then there's no reason for the original decision to be public. The courts decide on matters of law, so the publics view on the original decision is irrelevant, and up to the parties involved to convince the appeal judge their interpretation of the law is correct.
Once the matters been settled by the courts, it make sense to make everything public. But a no point during the process should or can public opinion influence the outcome.
Re:Dutch watchdog finds Apple App Store payment rules anti-c...
by mjburgess on Thursday October 07, 2021 @10:54AM
(#28787102)
I'm somewhat neutral on the issue. I agree, I also think that if a judge keeps it sealed for a short while, it's probably a reasonable thing to do.
Re:Dutch watchdog finds Apple App Store payment rules anti-c...
by emn13 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @11:02AM
(#28787233)
More likely, it's merely evidence it's a legally sound thing to do. That doesn't mean it's particularly reasonable, simply that it's not technically trivial to reject out of hand. It could equally be a symptom of regulatory capture; it's not like the judge gets to just do whatever they feel is fair (at least not without professional consequences).
Similarly: if the ruling is upheld Apple does not get to pay more because they - apparently improperly - asked for the previous ruling to be kept secret.
Courts should operate in a transparent manner whenever possible otherwise the trust in the legal system will erode and that trumps the commercial interests of any single company, even one as large as Apple.