News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evidence That ADHD Is a Genetic Disorder by Alex3917 on Friday August 12, 2011 @11:31AM (#2877661)
Thanks for your response. Here are a few issues I would raise though:

"It would be incorrect to conclude from these results that treatment makes no difference or is not worth pursuing"

They are defining treatment as either medication or therapy, not just medication.

"medication management-may only make a persistent long term difference if it is continued with the same intensity as during the MTA's initial 14 month period"

OK, but this is completely speculative. The researchers don't even give any reason to believe that this would be true, let alone point to any evidence.

"It could be that ADHD symptoms are positively correlated with psychosis."

The research states that all of the kids who developed psychosis were on ADHD meds, the group that was diagnosed with ADHD but was not medicated did not develop any psychosis at all.

"there is no indication that stimulant medication is wholly poor performing and that early studies indicating efficacy were flawed."

There were no early long-term studies indicating efficacy though, these are the only studies that were ever done.

There are no comments on this comment yet.