News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We need to take CO2 out of the sky by robomartin on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:25AM (#28774269)
> About 173,000 TW of energy strikes earth continuously. We have all the technology and we have all the resources we need to rapidly limit greenhouse gas emissions to sustainable levels and to start to remove CO2 from the atmosphere.

No, we don't. Great sounding assertion, no analysis whatsoever.

To start, read this:

https://storage.googleapis.com/pub-tools-public-publication-...

And then, this:

https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/reversing-ocean-acidification-aggr...

And then do this math. Let's use your number, "173,000 TW of energy" coming into our blue marble in space.

BTW, the Watt is a unit of POWER, not energy. Ignoring that minor detail for a second...

How is petroleum made?

Dead plants + dead animals + dead insects + possibly other stuff + lots of solar energy + millions of years

How much energy goes into creating one gallon of oil?

n<followed by an unimaginably large number of zeros>

How was it possible for humanity to affect such a dramatic change in atmospheric CO2 concentration?

Well, we burned oil.

Why was that so effective?

Because burning one gallon of oil, to put it in simple terms, is like burning an entire chunk of a forest...and we can burn a gallon of oil much faster than the equivalent forest area would burn. In other words, we can burn the result of a massive amount of raw matter, combined with a massive amount of solar energy and millions of years to produce it, in mere seconds.

In fact, one estimate says that one gallon of gasoline (not oil, that's worse) required some 98 tons of plants to produce:

https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/654287

From the article:

""Can you imagine loading 40 acres worth of wheat – stalks, roots and all – into the tank of your car or SUV every 20 miles?" asks ecologist Jeff Dukes, whose study will be published in the November issue of the journal Climatic Change.""

So, by burning one gallon of gasoline, we are burning the equivalent of some 40 acres of plant matter in roughly 20 minutes on every vehicle on earth (seat of the pants average, it's likely worse than that).

Wow! OK, how many gallons of oil do we burn per year?

Barrels. We burn about 35 BILLION barrels per year:

https://www.worldometers.info/oil/

BILLION, not million.

Going back to my "it's a closed system" observation. All we have is some amount of energy coming in and some being lost to space. No magical vacuum cleaner to help us fix anything. And we have resources, minerals, etc. under and above ground. That's it.

What you have to balance in an equation when evaluating a proposed solution is the amount of energy it took to create the materials we used to be able to release so much CO2 into the atmosphere. It will not take less energy to claw it back, in any form. It will take more. Even if we found parity and it took the same amount of energy, it would be an impossibly large number. Even if we found a magical juju bean that could do it for 1/10 the the energy, it would still be an unimaginably large number, not to mention what it would take to go mine, process, transport, deploy and clean-up the magical juju beans.

Just a little bit of thought and high school math quickly reveals we are being sold fantasy after fantasy. We can't fix this. We need to start talking about adapting. There is no Superman.

Re:We need to take CO2 out of the sky by Ma8ee on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @12:19PM (#28774916)
About your first link from 2014: renewable energy is already cheaper.

About your second link: no one has claimed that we all damage already done is reversible.

Apparently I have to teach you that power is energy per unit of time, that is we have 173,000 TJ/s. And then we can do some simple calculation from energy equivalence of 35 billion barrels of oil (213,000,000 TJ) and find that corresponds to about 20 minutes of sunlight hitting Earth. Or calculating from power instead, we burn 6.75 GW of oil, or about 3e-11 of the incoming sun power. There's plenty of energy available, and nowadays sun energy is cheaper than coal. You don't even need high school math for this.

So, as you see, the "not closed system", is kind of relevant. What is irrelevant is how much plant matter that is required to produce said oil. No one, absolutely no one, has suggested that we should make new oil by burying plant matter for a long time.

Re:We need to take CO2 out of the sky by robomartin on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:59PM (#28777654)
Nice bit of high school math after a google search. Good job. Pointless though.

You are pointing at solar energy coming into the planet as if it were some magical juju bean that can solve all of our problems. Well, it isn't. Had you actually read the report from which you got some of this information you would know just how wrong you are in trying to reduce the entirety of reality into a single variable: Solar energy. The whole idea is preposterous.

In your attempt to look smart and convert power to energy using a google search you fail to understand the key difference between power and energy in real life.

Using a simple example: The solar array I built in the back of my house can produce a theoretical maximum of 14,000 W any given instant (power). Assuming that is true (not even close), this means I could collect a theoretical 104 kW hours of energy over eight hours (also not true). Talking about energy is pointless because we do not use energy, we use power, we use the instantaneous version of, in this case, using electrons to do some work.

If you add-up the energy production capacity of all the power plants in the US (multiply their power output by 24 hours and add them all up) you can easily believe we have enough to charge 300 million electric cars. And that would be wrong. We do not have enough POWER generating capacity to support such a fleet. The energy calculation isn't correct because you can't use it to deliver power beyond the instantaneous power delivery capacity we have. The only way this would be true is if our future electric cars sat there for 24 hours to charge.

And then there's the reality that converting solar energy to anything useful is a horribly inefficient process. My 13 kW array covers about 80 square meters. That is a theoretical 80 kW (round numbers) of solar energy. At best, with all conditions being perfect, I have generated 11 kW. My average peak over several years in operation is about 8 kW. So 10% of the energy that hits it, at the PEAK moment in the day, much worse on either side of that curve. Counting energy, when what you need is power is a fantasy.

Oher solar energy conversion processes are even worse, as an example, geothermal is about 2% efficient, at best.

Do not reduce reality to a single variable. It isn't. It is a complex multivariate problem.

> About your first link from 2014: renewable energy is already cheaper.

You probably didn't even read it. Did you? The paper has NOTHING to do with cost. It has everything to do with "can we achieve zero emissions with renewables". And that means all renewables, not just solar. The answer is a solid "no".

> About your second link: no one has claimed that we all damage already done is reversible.

No idea what you are saying. You probably didn't read that either.

Re:We need to take CO2 out of the sky by Ma8ee on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @05:02PM (#28778380)
No, I don’t read the old, long papers after a short glance seeing that their initial assumptions are wrong or the subject doesn’t seem to relevant. If you have a point to make, make it. Then you can cite papers if say your numbers need some backing by actual research.

I really get the feeling that you don’t understand how power relates to energy. What are you trying to say about peak power capacity and charging of cars? You do know that not all cars are driven at exactly the same time or are charged at exactly the same time?

Also, of course we need to increase our electricity production if more things, like cars, are going to be run on electricity.

The efficiency of solar panels doesn’t matter much. You remember that ratio between incoming energy and energy usage? We have a lot of zeros to take from. It doesn’t matter that the average solar panel only converts about a fifth of incoming energy, because the incoming energy is abundant and completely free. The same argument can be made about geothermal. And the same argument can be made about storing energy as hydrogen. Yes, the conversation will be inefficient, but that doesn’t matter because you do it sunny, windy days, electricity will be more or less free.

Finally, I’m sorry you think my argument is too simple. But calling it magical juju doesn’t refute it. The amount of solar radiation hitting earth is a very well established, and easy to understand, scientific fact. And if you remember, that fact was used to refute your statement that earth should be seen as a closed system. You didn’t even try to defend that statement, so I hope you never try to use it again without embarrassment.

Re:We need to take CO2 out of the sky by robomartin on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:22PM (#28780643)
It is a closed system. Energy in -> Energy out. No magic.

What this means is that we don't get to claim "and then a miracle occurs" when proposing a solutions. This is exactly what all so-called solutions boil down to. Including what you are talking about.

You are citing the total energy landing on a hemisphere and completely ignoring that we can't harvest even a small fraction of that. Solar energy is very, very far from free. I built a 13 kW array on my property, I can assure you it was not free. I can also assure likely produced far more CO2 than it will ever save us. This is where you need to understand manufacturing and construction. I won't even go into the shit I had to go through with the County of Los Angeles. I have 64,000 POUNDS of concrete anchoring this array to the ground --which LA County forced upon me. How much CO2 do you think it cost to produce, transport and install that? How about the non-trivial structure it is mounted on? I could go on.

This idea that solar energy is free is just plain silly.

You are refusing to read one of the most scientifically honest papers ever done on the question of whether or not solar energy (actually, all renewables combined) can stop atmospheric CO2 build-up and reverse it and you actually want to school me on having a valid argument.

And, speaking of energy vs. power. Lots of sunlight falls above and below latitudes where converting it into other usable forms of energy is just pointless. If you want to be honest about solar energy, well, you have to do the math. It isn't what you think it is. Do you even have solar?

Here's the output of my 13 kW array on an average day:

https://i.imgur.com/LTMNDO1.png

Do you see what happens? No, it isn't magical juju beans. You can't quote some theoretical number and actually believe this stuff is usable.

Besides, you could convert the entire planet to the most optimal forms of solar and wind power and you would still do nothing to stop atmospheric CO2 accumulation. Not sure why you are even arguing about solar. It's pointless.

> I really get the feeling that you don’t understand how power relates to energy. What are you trying to say about peak power capacity and charging of cars? You do know that not all cars are driven at exactly the same time or are charged at exactly the same time?

That's very funny. I have a nasty habit. I do not open my mouth unless I know what I am talking about. Which means I go way --ridiculously so-- out of my way to research things as far as necessary in order to understand and verify my claims. In the case of cars charging in the US, I actually developed a mathematical model that included behavioral elements and charging cars across our various time zones.

This, for example, is one of the outputs of the analysis:

https://i.imgur.com/wTwm82a.png

This includes considering such things as a portion of the fleet fast-charging while others slow charge. I considers the effect of people going to work and coming home at different times across our six time zones, etc. I am not typing stuff I pull out of my ass my friend. You can either make the effort to understand and attempt to do your own math or just ignore it and believe whatever you might wish.

The only thing that would be better than this model would be to write more complex behavioral simulation code and take into account far more variables than I did. I'll do that one day when I have the time. I don't think the end-result will be radically different from the simpler model.

Like I said, unlike most people, I go very far towards actually understanding things before I open my mouth.

Hey. Live long and prosper.

Re:We need to take CO2 out of the sky by robomartin on Thursday October 07, 2021 @12:52AM (#28782120)
Back to my nasty habit. I said I do not open my mouth unless I know what I am talking about and I do enough research to confirm it. This also means I am constantly checking my assumptions.

Back to energy and electric vehicles. I told you that my models predicted a requirement for a massive increase in energy generation capacity to be able to go to full electric vehicles. I then shared an image from one of my simulation model run calculations. This one:

https://i.imgur.com/wTwm82a.png

It shows a "new energy" need in the range of roughly 900 to 1,400 GW. Unimaginable. Right? That's over a thousand 1 GW class nuclear power plants.

I am delusional. Right?

Well, I decided to, once again, check my assumptions and math. They make sense to me. And then, looking around some more, I came across this from earlier this year:

https://youtu.be/ESIjxVudERY?t=3680

Here you have Elon Musk saying (paraphrasing) "If we convert all of our transportation to electric, electricity demand more than doubles". He goes on to explain that it isn't just about generation, it is, as I said, about transportation as well (which really means it is about POWER, not energy).

So, what does "more than doubles" mean?

Well, let's start with what our current energy generation capacity is in the US:

https://www.publicpower.org/resource/americas-electricity-ge...

As of February of this year, it sits at 1,200 GW.

Elon's "more than doubles" means we need more than 1,200 GW in new energy generation capacity. Interestingly enough, my model gave a range of between 900 GW and 1,400 GW. I created these models about five years ago.

Yeah, I think I know what I am talking about.

Re:We need to take CO2 out of the sky by robomartin on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:36AM (#28784937)
And here's another one:

We don't get to use all the solar energy landing on the planet. Not even close.

Why?

Because, if you did, you would kill every single forest and all of agriculture. You would kill every single animal. You would likely kill the oceans. You might kill bacteria, insects and seriously disrupt weather. I can't even think about all the variables that would be deeply disturbed if humanity decided we are going to attempt to use a big chunk of what solar energy lands on the planet.

And blocking it from space? Seriously? Again, refer to the prior paragraph, let's go ahead and kill everything on earth.

These ideas might sound good after a beer or two but are nothing less than laughable once someone sits down and really puts pen to paper.

We are proposing to mess with forces we can't possibly understand. I have said this many times, we can't even take care of small-scale ecosystems and we are actually lending credence to nut-cases suggesting such things as deploying devices in space to block the sun. Wonderful.