One of the most blinkered views I've seen on HN. Who exactly do you think benefits from libraries the most? It sure isn't people who have a lazy $200 sitting around.
There’s no reason why we should deny people below the poverty line the ability to read books outside the confines of the library walls. The entire functionality of the library is to be a public good, providing the products and services that allow everyone to enrich themselves. If it wasn’t, it would be a weird nationalized chain of book stores.
But to short circuit this insanity a bit: why. Why is this recommendation desirable? Can you point to any negative impact that has occurred at any library that has just stopped charging late fees and switched to “bring back old book to get new books”, as has occurred here? If not… why are you so determined to invent a new solution without understanding the library’s usage demographics, when what they picked for themselves seems to be working.
> there are a vast number of people who have housing but do not have $200 of liquid capital to drop as a library deposit.
Be that as it may, they aren't prevented from using library under this proposal. Those who care to will somehow scrape the deposit together, and their money is entirely safe provided they don't damage borrowed materials or don't return them for half a year.
It's a heck of a lot easier to collect that from a deposit your already have.
Not sure where you live, but almost 2/3 of American households don't have enough cash to cover a $500 emergency[0]. What makes you think they can spare $200 for a library deposit?
[0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/maggiemcgrath/2016/01/06/63-of-...
OK, I will bite. What makes me think they can spare $200 for a library deposit?
The fact that it (1) it doesn't come up as an emergency (you can budget for it in advance) and (2) they know they can have all of it back whenever they want to take a break from borrowing from the library, and have returned all their loans. (Unless they are idiots who trash books.) The psychology of "I'm losing 200 dollars" isn't there.
Whereas a $500 emergency is just: oh no; goodbye, money!
People have a way of not having money when they have to cover some unexpected pure loss. Yet somehow they have iPhones, Playstations, designer sneakers and jeans, ...
And then again, maybe some people really, actually cannot do it. So, have a $20 deposit with more modest borrowing privileges. Or some other creative way.
> so many fallacies
Would you say I presented anywhere near, oh, six?
> hard to know where to start
You could enumerate the fallacies and misunderstandings in order of appearance, then pick a tiny random number in that range and begin with that one.
Why would someone wish to do that? No one is required to disabuse you of your ignorance. Especially given the trollish comments you've plastered all over this sub.
It is not only unreasonable ands unrealistic to expect these people to be able to save up a $200 deposit, it is also bad customer experience and restricting libraries' market access. If libraries were a tech company any decent product owner would shoot down the idea in a flash. a book
No privileged language here!
It's a lot of families.
To get a sense of how many, 40% of Americans surveyed say that they would have trouble paying an unexpected $400 expense. That they'd have to sell something or neglect other bills, or it would otherwise be a challenge, or impossible.
https://www.cnbc.com/2019/07/20/heres-why-so-many-americans-...
But meanwhile... why? Wny not just... eliminate late fees instead? As several cities have already done, without disaster?
Are there any downsides that any library which has done this has experienced?
A poor person needing a nail gun and air compressor to fix up their shack should just be able to get that from the library, and not have to pay some capitalistic swine like Home Depot or whoever.
No late fees ... return it next week, next month, whenever y'know?
In practice, there’s more hurdles for tools, since they have more risk of harming the user, but they seem like they’re possible to overcome.
Oh look, we aren’t the first ones to have this idea: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tool_library “ Given their increasing popularity and proven history of success, tool libraries and tool banks are now playing a role in the sharing economy and can be found in local public libraries and makerspaces, for instance. There are software platforms for managing tool and other types of lending libraries”
Libraries are a public good. If someone gets a few dollars extra value out of it "unfairly" no harm is really done. Unless one likes to kick down...
You come off as very sheltered and privileged in these comments. Have some empathy for others.
By the way, if you need a safe/dry place to exist, and the library is it, why would you need to borrow books to take somewhere else? Books also need a safe/dry place to exist!
If you can't put down a $200 refundable (with interest) balance, how are you maintaining a place where you can take the books?
Also, even homeless people are allowed to borrow books from a public library, in fact! But, no, there are many many people who struggle and hustle and have a place to live but don't have an extra $200 to leave sitting at the library.
You don't need to be ashamed that you literally don't know any of them, assuming you live in the USA, America is a really segregated (and I don't just mean racially) society. It's not your choice or fault. But you could be aware of it, believe me, to ask that question you have no idea how a good chunk of the USA lives.
(But also... can you imagine any business that required a $200 deposit to have an account with them, and how that would effect their business? Like imagine grubhub or blueapron or something. Even people that can afford $200 really don't want to begin their relationship with a business by giving them $200 to hold. Occasionally a 'business' which someone really has no choice but to use, like the electric utility, gets away with requiring a deposit. The mission of a public library is serving as many people as it can, a policy that drastically reduced the number of people interested in using the library would be a huge failure for the library).
Yes I do, and I wouldn't lend books, or anything else, into that environment.
But anyway, I'm glad you're not running any of my municipal services, and am glad that you (hopefully) aren't my neighbor!
So, okay, you _know_ how many people couldn't afford the $200 deposit, and don't see this as a problem because you don't think they deserve library service?
I'm sorry, I misunderstood your original point, or I wouldn't have bothered talking to you.
So it's OK for you to have standards: someone who merely doesn't subscribe to the whole white, liberal, upper-middle class socio-econo-political guilt-ridden value system is not fit to live next door to you.
But a library must not have lending standards that even smell of having any socio-economic entanglement.
It takes little imagination to see that the scheme could be shaped in ways to accommodate the very poor. E.g. there doesn't have to be a minimum deposit of $200; a substantially lower deposit like $20 or $10 could some borrowing privileges. Book or two, not twelve kind a thing. Plus any number of other mitigating solutions.
Memberships would not require a deposit. Like to log in to an Internet terminal with your library ID would not require one. Lost library cards could be free as well.
Needless to say, this would be completely ridiculous outside of America. If I think about libraries in, hmm, Austria or Japan doing anything this, I just have shake my head, no.
There is a broad population segment in America that has no respect though.
You go up to the desk, say you want to cancel your account, hand in your card and get your money back, no questions asked.
My dude, I don't think you really understand the goals or objectives of public libraries.
Unlike Whole Foods, though, as a public good (and already funded by the taxes of everyone who walks in the doors), libraries have a mission to make books accessible to as many people as possible, not just those who can pay what's a $200 fee, nor are they trying to make a profit, so they have even less incentive than Whole Foods to punish their patrons.
That makes no sense; you are not talking about a refundable deposit that is only deducted in confirmed cases of shoplifting. People do not borrow food from Whole foods and then fail to return it.
Deposits are standard operating practice in rental businesses. Have you ever rented a tool? They will put the replacement cost of the tool (possibly into the hundreds of dollars) as a charge on your credit card, which is then reversed when you return it, minus the $15 rental or whatever.
"A refundable deposit that is only deducted in confirmed cases of shoplifting" is, for all practical purposes, an additional fee that would remain out of your pocket for as long as you want to have a right to the library, even if you have no intention to steal, which is more or less the same as Whole Foods just deciding to charge $200 to any potential shopgoer for the right to enter their store. Refundable or not, that's $200 that is gone from your pocket until you either move (and then pay another $200 fee at a different city's library?) or give up your membership.
Our access to libraries are already funded by our taxes. We've already paid for access. Why disincentivize people to use what we all pay for, other than to justify spending less tax money on libraries because not as many people are going?
> Have you ever rented a tool?
Yes, actually. Most recently, Home Depot just put a $30 charge for a $3500 lawnmower on my card -- with the threat that if I don't return it within a certain amount of time I'll owe it in total. They did not ever put the total cost of $3500 on my card.
But I think damaged books are usually those that are used frequently. Rare and expensive books tend to be in great shape, even if they are lend out all the time. You just need to register in time for the next available extension slot. Also expensive/rare books are less frequently for take home available.
A patron is generally someone who pays.
Nobody is paying in this situation; there is a deposit which is refundable, with reasonable interest competitive with bank savings accounts in the area.
Where I live, the (one and only) power company charges deposits against new accounts with no credit or bad credit:
https://app.bchydro.com/accounts-billing/bill-payment/custom...
Why would a library not charge deposits for borrowing? Because people need to be able to take books home (as opposed to reading in the library) more than they need electricity?
An alternative question could be: Why doesn't BC make electricity as available to their poorest citizens as NY makes books available to theirs?
Late fees: pay small fee, borrow books.
No late fees: pay for replacement, borrow books.
I think the best system would be something like a $200 fully refundable deposit, plus late fees (deducted from your deposit account). Account must not drop below $180 due to accrued late fees, or use of library is suspended.
If you don't return books for an excessively long period, like six months, their value is automatically deducted from your deposit on top of accrued late fees; then you may keep the books.