Sounds like the BMJ dont trust this chap and are questioning his financial interests. Therefore I would question his motives with regard to this article, he isnt very forthcoming which is usually indicative of having something to hide.
The article you mentioned only refers to stock portfolio and potential conflicts of interest regarding policy decisions on performing antibody tests.
The statement that was quoted in this discussion is about an entirely unrelated subject: the prevalence of long Covid. The initial claim is that the statement is supported by data from the Office for National Statistics.
If you want to question John Bell's claim regarding the prevalence of long Covid, just check if his statement is corroborated by the data. Either it's supported or not.
There is a very good way to verify the claims: check the data.
Dragging in questions regarding antibody test policies, stock portfolios, and potential conflicts of interest just sound like cheap character assassination attempts that have absolutely no relation with the prevalence of long Covid.
Don't accept things blindly because you agree with them (or the converse), "be a good judge of who is a good judge".
If that's what you're going with then you only need to verify the data to either refute or verify his claim.
Everything else is just noise at this point.
You didn't even bothered to look, did you?
https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthan...
That’s fallacious. There are loads of professors spewing bullshit, including about their field, including at Oxford. It says nothing about the validity of the point they are making. Particularly after the point has been filtered through journalists with a questionable understanding of science.
No, not really. The fallacious bit is blindly and outright dismissing any statement, along with attacking and accusing anything a researcher says as being "spewing bullshit", just because you didn't liked hearing it.
Eve though I agree that appeals to authority are no way to get close to the truth, what we are seeing here is pure denialism and a primal anti-intellectual attitude directed towards a researcher from a reputable university just because he dared point out that initial conservative estimates might have been conservative.
To be quite clear, John Bell does not dictate the truth just because he is a professor of medicine at Oxford. But that is not the problem. The problem is actually trying to attack him just because he had the audacity to quote statistics on the real-world incidence of long Covid and state that initial estimates were off.
That is not nearly good enough.
This is HN. We should be posting peer-reviewed research results, not just-any-professor-in-the-field's-feelings.
That's a completely baseless statement, and there is some serious fuckery going on here, either with the article, or the supposed expert they're citing.
Yes, he's no rando posting stuff on his Facebook page, nor is he a rapper or media personality. He's an expert from a reputable university that made solid contributions to the fight against COVID-19 , and he is quoting data from the Office for National Statistics. In the very least we should give him the benefit of the doubt.
Even though it's true that appeals to authority don't cut it, that does not mean you are entitled to dismiss any comment you don't like by resorting to personal attacks.
Either way, spinning the debate to try to focus it on the messenger instead of the message is not a productive or honest way to debate a subject. We should try our best to keep the signal/noise ratio up, specially in topics so prone to disinformation.
The guy quoted for said statement is a professor of medicine of a reputable university, so he does have the authority thing sorted out.
Also, I feel the quote means something different than the original interpretation. After reading the article, it seems that John Bell simply states that a) long Covid is "more complicated than people assume", and b) it's incidence is lower than initial (and conservative) estimates.
The article mentions that "half of people suffering from long Covid may not have it."
And that's pretty much it.
There is no harm in improving our understanding of the real world effects of a disease.