Re:‘Jean Sibelius’ Review: An Early Finale
by cranky908canuck on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:14PM
(#28805721)
The Fifth was heavily revised, and yes, you have to be in the right mood (west coast fog, for example), to get the first bits. Also, I find that the very end as written really "drops me on the floor" in a lot of performances; I have an old Karajan recording where he ignores the notated rhythm and bangs off those last chords really fast, and that works for me in a way that other endings do not.
Re:‘Jean Sibelius’ Review: An Early Finale
by DrStormyDaniels on Sunday October 17, 2021 @04:16PM
(#28899416)
Thanks, I'll have to look the recording up.
That piece is one of the few classical recordings in my music library, and also one that helped crystallize how much execution can influence the quality of a classical composition. In some versions, excessive percussions just ruin it.
(Its best to listen to the whole symphony, the first 2 movements aren't bad but they are definitely prelims, I'd have something to read at the same time.)