You're still misrepresenting the actual words in the NA article. NA didn't say "image extrapolation is new". What they actually wrote was the "generative modeling approach" was new. Excerpt:
>DeepMind set out to develop a machine-learning tool that can bring a new level of precision to these efforts, [...] It did so by using a generative modeling approach,
That's basically an accurate short summary of the longer Nature journal article.
>or “AI” is what’s not great and doesn’t help trend of people rushing to portray something as “AI” when it’s just the same sort of data analytics
This is really just the AI vs AGI[1] distinction. If you're not aware, the label "AI" (naked with no modifiers) has already been downgraded to "weak AI". So the more difficult "AI" that nobody solved yet is now elevated with a new label of "AGI" or "strong AI" to help sort out the confusion.
- "AI" which implies "weak AI" : analogous to "we don't care that planes and drones don't really 'fly' because even if they don't flap their wings like birds, it still solves a problem." Analogy is "AI":"fly"
--vs--
- "AGI" artificial general intelligence: solve the very hard problem of going from logic gates to "learning" everything like a child's brain does. In this definition, AlphaZero beating every human chess player and all previous computer chess engines is "not really AI".
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_general_intelligenc...
The DeepMind work is fantastic. The media spin isn't - and I don't mean DM's PR team, I mean the opinions shouted from the rooftops across blogs and popular media (including the MIT Technology Review [2]). DM's technique still falls squarely in the domain of extrapolation from recent imagery - exactly what some commenters here are pointing out was developed decades ago. There's little evidence that the new approach can robustly handle the development of new convection or non-linear evolution of mesoscale systems. That's obvious in the animation that's being shared - within the envelope of the linear system over the UK, the structure of storm cells is highly persistent and the overall motion is linear. But you can readily identify areas of unrealistic growth/decay (usually attributed to numerical diffusion in pure image processing techniques, e.g. semi-lagrangian advection of the background OF field).
That matters because the practical application(s) of precipitation nowcasting are really limited to things like, "it will rain in XX minutes at location YY". As long as there is rain on the radar, that problem is 'solved' about as precisely as you would ever need.
IMHO the biggest innovation here relates to the computational efficiency of the approach. Probably a total beast to train the DGMR system, but inferences in a handful of seconds? That's awesome - it opens up new possibilities for _analysis_ (e.g. sampling a large ensemble from the latent space of plausible future states of the radar imagery and producing highly-tuned probabilistic forecasts or incorporating stochastic mechanism that may yield more realistic projections of cellular growth/decay within linear systems) which have thus far been computationally intractable.
The next leap forward in nowcasting is convective initiation. That would be a legitimate game changer in meteorology.
[1]: https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/10/9/555/htm [2]: https://www.technologyreview.com/2021/09/29/1036331/deepmind...
This is according to whom? Who was it that 'downgraded [AI] to "weak AI"'?
The "who" is all of us. _We_ all collectively watered-down "AI" based on how we _used_ "AI" in mainstream news articles and VC-backed startups or any company today throwing around the word "AI" associated with technology. I was making a descriptive and not prescriptive statement.
See that the gp complains that a "deep generative model neural net" is _not_ "AI". My point is that virtually all uses of naked "AI" is now understood to be examples of "weak AI". Therefore, making a meta-comment on every article that mentions "AI" (instead of "AGI") as "that's not really AI" ... has become superfluous.
Consider the phrase "YC-backed AI startup": https://www.google.com/search?q=yc-backed+%22ai+startup%22
Let's imagine if each of those stories was submitted to HN. Do we really need to make a meta-comment in each thread saying, "What they're doing is not really AI and I hate how the AI label is slapped on everything!" ?
We already know that Real Generalized Artificial Intelligence is not actually here (maybe not for decades) -- and yet -- people we don't control keep using the label "AI". Now what do we do? If one remembers they're talking about "weak AI" whenever they use the naked "AI" terminology, we just let it go and move on.
No, it's not my opinion. I'm making factual statements of language evolution which doesn't care about my opinion. A bunch of other people we have no control over have already used "AI" the way it's being used now. I think you're trying to be combative and argumentative about the word "AI" and I don't know why.
I ask you to click on the google link for "YC-backed AI startup". What would be your definition of "AI" such that all those headlines can be interpreted correctly? How is everyone using that term? And when Amazon/Apple/Google/Microsoft announce that they have a new feature "AI assisted this or AI-powered that" ... what do they mean? This thread's article used the term "AI" and "AI system" to refer to DeepMind's GAN neural network. What did the author mean by "AI" in his text? Certainly not AGI. So what's left?
I'm pointing out that it is your opinion that 'the label "AI" (naked with no modifiers) has already been downgraded to "weak AI".' You explained why you think so, but that's just ...why you think so. You're not some kind of authority on how terms should be used and you have no reason to admonish the other user to use it in the way you like.
Btw, note that I'm not interested in your disagreement with the OP about "weak" vs. "strong" AI. As far as I'm concerned, you're both trying to apply what you know from Science Fiction to the real world. The only thing that exists in the real world today that's called "AI" by any authoritative source is the field of research in artificial intelligence. It is common in the lay press to describe systems created by AI researchers as "AI" or "AIs" and it's even more common to refer to deep learning reserach synechdochically as "AI", or "machine learning", but those are terminological mistakes that are to be expected from people outside a field of research as varied and broad as AI. Researchers in the field, of course, don't ever call their work "AI"! Well, not in published research at least. I mean, that's a three-strong-reject offence. One'd be laughed out of the field...
So I hope this clarifies the confusion and the motivation for my comment. You have an opinion, strongly held, based on poor, irrelevant knowledge and you forcefully support it. I thought, since I have a bit of knowledge in the matter, I should set the record straight: That's just, like, your opinion, man.
Yes, I agree I'm not and I previously said, "I was making a descriptive and not prescriptive statement." If you're not familiar with descriptive-vs-prescriptive: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem
>to admonish the other user to use it in the way you like.
To be clear, I didn't admonish him. I thought he misunderstood how _others_ were (mis)using the "AI" term. I didn't disagree with the OP about "AI" and did not instruct him to use it differently.
>It is common in the lay press to describe systems created by AI researchers as "AI" or "AIs" and it's even more common to refer to deep learning reserach synechdochically as "AI", or "machine learning", but those are terminological mistakes that are to be expected
When you write, "It is common in the lay press to describe systems created ..." you just restated the same descriptive-vs-prescriptive explanation I did.
And yes! Others we don't control keep repeating "terminological mistakes" as you call it. That's my point and you're restating it in different words. I just happened to use the word "downgraded" instead of "terminological mistakes". Maybe there's a language barrier and it's that particular word that bothers you?
>Researchers in the field, of course, don't ever call their work "AI"!
Exactly! So now we must hold two contradictory facts (not opinions) in our head:
(1) academic researchers don't call their work "AI"
(2) ~2 billion search results for the term "AI" of which most usage are "terminological mistakes" : https://www.google.com/search?q=%22AI%22+software
So the reality is that we still have 2 billion pages using "AI" that didn't obey any authority such as academic researchers telling them how to use it. Now what? I guess we can complain, "I wish 2 billion webpages didn't slap "AI" on everything!"
Has that changed anything? Was that complaint about others' language (mis)usage productive to the discussion? In my opinion, I don't think so.
As analogy, if you insist that peanuts/cashews/almonds correct definition is "legumes" and not "nuts" -- you still have to simultaneously hold another contradictory definition in your head to understand that others are still referring to those as "nuts". Descriptive-vs-Prescriptive.
EDIT reply to: >"So we agree that 'the label "AI" (naked with no modifiers) has already been downgraded to "weak AI"' is just your opinion, correct?"
You're playing argument games trying to trap me in "my opinion" instead of noticing that you said the same thing I did. No it's not my opinion; it's a factual observation of what people are doing. It's also not my opinion that you explained what the world does as "terminological mistakes" -- a factual observation -- which was a restatement of what I already said. This means we're going around in circles.
In any case, I would like to ask you why you think academic researchers in AI field don't call their work "AI"?