News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The reputation economy is turning us into conformists (20... by mc32 on Monday October 04, 2021 @10:27AM (#28747160)
No normal person will deny this.

But there is no comparison to a small population being affected (ironically in the USSR, lots of artists and authors got not only blacklisted but sent to the Gulags --gee, I wonder if they wrote to Stalin on behalf of their brethren) to potentially anyone and everyone being a potential subject at any moment for something otherwise innocuous.

What’s more this is much worse. It’s not about a singular subject (communist sympathizer) but just about anything at any moment. It's a shifting landscape so much so that there is internecine sniping among all groups.

Today you can’t even make a genuine faux pas without the risk of someone coming down on you and risking your livelihood. That’s quite different.

If Pelosi said off handedly, you know Trump did a couple of things right, or you know I don’t agree 100% with everything BLM she’ll be in trouble and she’s the top politician outside the president. Imagine a school teacher…

Re:The reputation economy is turning us into conformists (20... by klyrs on Monday October 04, 2021 @10:49AM (#28747450)
> But there is no comparison to a small population being affected to potentially anyone and everyone being a potential subject.

If I may paraphrase... there's no comparison between oppressing a minority I don't belong to, and the entire population being subjected to the same risk.

Re:The reputation economy is turning us into conformists (20... by mc32 on Monday October 04, 2021 @10:52AM (#28747495)
It doesn't matter how you put it.

If you say "tax the rich 95%." That's bad. "Tax everyone 95%" That's really bad. I don't understand how you cannot see that. The fewer people affected by something, the less evil it is even if it's evil.

I mean, what are you saying, H-wood blacklisting was bad, therefore what we see in social media ostracizing is acceptable? That seems... strange.

Of course not all sympathizers of communism also agreed with death camps, re-education, stifling of progress, etc., etc., but they tacitly contributed to to those bad things. A young person, or someone who thinks they are being funny or whatever caught in a bad moment is different from someone who knowingly supports tyrannical forms of government.

Re:The reputation economy is turning us into conformists (20... by shadowgovt on Monday October 04, 2021 @10:37AM (#28747302)
Modern bidirectional communications tools make it easy to wide-cast a message and then have that message responded to by potentially millions of receivers.

I think we don't respect the power we wield often enough. That's a terrible capability to provide via a system that also encourages you to blurt something out in 280 characters or less. Every single tweet is a shout from a mountaintop (and since it's time-stamped and on the timeline forever, that shout echoes perpetually).

Additionally, that infrastructure incentivizes gravitation towards some flat-mass-"centroid" of acceptable cultural practice, and there's no particular guarantee that such a thing across the bulk of humanity is either possible or desirable.