News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by DanielBMarkham on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:17AM (#28737313)
The overseas market, specifically China, probably plays a much bigger role in self-censoring cinema than most people are comfortable admitting. Nobody wants good cinema, movies that dig into and challenge the human condition. They want money. In the last 20-30 years, we have seen the strip-mall-ization of the movie theater. Every city has at least one, they all look the same, and drop in at any time and you'll see the same kinds of movies: cool-looking, easy, bowlderized, with paint-by-the-numbers plots.

I love real cinema. For all intents and purposes it's gone now. We need a new art form to take its place.

A big part of the problem with any commercial art form is the plethora of folks who love to be reductionist in one way or another. Leads in TV shows from the 1950s forward wanted to know and control how many lines they spoke. John Wayne famously gave the advice to another actor that if you're leaving a scene, first move in the opposite direction and then leave the way you're supposed to. Gives you a bit more screen time. (Apologies that I cannot source that offhand)

Once everything becomes reductionist, it's then much easier to argue about some oversimplified version of the art than the contents of the art itself. Were there enough tall people in that film? Did that essay have the right amount of third-grade level adjectives? Is the playwright using a meter for the supporting roles? If so, what is it?

We can go on and on about such things because they are easier to measure, require almost no understanding of the art form itself, and lead to all sorts of debates. Sometimes I think the number one rule of modern media is "I don't care what you're arguing about, just argue about something!"

If we placed the story first, and only created anything in an art form to support and enhance that story, we'd get all sorts of interesting and self-challenging art, depending on which artist is telling the story. Whatever trivial reductionist thing you'd like to experience, there'd be art that let you experience it. But if we try to create and tell stories through art by way of committee and marketing research, it's just going to be more and more bland populist pablum.

The saddest part of all of this is not that businesses are acting in their best interests. The saddest part is what it says about the average consumer. I love modern theater even though it's a completely new art, but I try very hard not to do the "reverse math" and figure out just what the creators think of me. Otherwise I'd get pretty pissed.

Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by cm2187 on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:31AM (#28737449)
I don’t know if hollywood has ever been anything else. I watched a documentary recently on the action movies of the 80s and 90s [1]. The part that was eye opening was the interview of Mario Kassar, who produced some of my favorite movies as a teenager in the 90s: Rambo, Total Recall, T2, Basic Instinct, etc. He talks about what he puts in his films literally like a farmer talks about grain for his pigs.

It has always been primarily a business targeting the lowest possible common denominator of the largest possible audience. And as the developed world expanded, that denominator shrank. Hence everything Marvel now.

[1] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt8840400/

Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by DanielBMarkham on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:39AM (#28737525)
This is the best rebuttal to my thesis. Thanks.

There is a tension between art and commercial art. Beethoven should have never written that battle symphony.

When done well, I think you can get both. Start with the story and then weave in the commercial aspects. Or start with the story and only choose to finance movies that have both art and commercial value. What you can't do is start with the commercial side and then try to hammer in a good story. There have been a few masters that managed to pull that off, but it's rare. Add in committee-management instead of having an artist's eye and it becomes total crap.

It's in nobody's interest to only have arthouse flicks that nobody watches. Happily it's not an either-or decision. Good drama will draw in the commercial part than can then be exploited. Everybody's happy. What I'm seeing now is that majority of films start with a locked-in fanbase and then try to do their best at creating an n+1 episode. That's how they're getting around the quality problem: they make it moot. They know the locked-in fanbase is coming no matter what they produce, and if it's a real stinker? Well hell, all of the press and arguing about how bad it is will just drive up interest for n+2. Not only is that not trying to mix a good story in with a commercial line, that's putting the story quality pretty far down the list. It's noticeable.

ADD: I'd say that in the heyday of arthouse flicks, say 65-80, you had the peak of movies that covered both bases well. Nobody's doing another Midnight Cowboy.

Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by moogly on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:24AM (#28737388)
On the China thing: Why don't we let the ones who want to censor movies just do it on their own instead of precensoring them? This used to happen a lot. Is it really that expensive to cut out a few shots or use compositing to obscure things?

I believe it's still done for so-called in-flight entertainment.

Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by DanielBMarkham on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:28AM (#28737426)
Good question. To clarify, in China any company or business enterprise has to have political officers sprinkled throughout. This makes sure that the organization is following the party line appropriately.

So when I said the problem was China, I didn't mean the Chinese market, I meant that a huge amount of money currently being spent financing film entertainment comes from groups like this. They kill these kinds of things before they ever get financed.

Most folks don't talk about the money side of movies. It's nothing like talking about which star is in rehab or where the MCU is heading with its reboot. But at the end of the day, that's the thing driving content creation.

Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by dragonwriter on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:48AM (#28737599)
> On the China thing: Why don't we let the ones who want to censor movies just do it on their own instead of precensoring them?

Because its more cost effective to consider the whole market when making the movie to start with.

> I believe it's still done for so-called in-flight entertainment

In-flight entertainment isn't way down the list of money drivers. “Chinese first-run sales” is a lot higher. So the power of the latter on how movies are initially crafted is big, while the former is negligible.

Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by Zababa on Sunday October 03, 2021 @11:19AM (#28737840)
You're assuming that these films are made first for the USA. As an example, the last Fast & Furious made more money in China as compared to the USA, and that's with a Taiwan controversy: https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt5433138/
Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by 2ion on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:27AM (#28737419)
I think in a lot of "markets", uselessly drawn out sex scenes were just never there. In fact, I find this trait of Western movie and TV making highly annoying. Because those sex scenes are always the same. If you have seen a few, you've seen all of them, more variety only to be found in real porn. After N repetitions, TV and movie tropes just become boring rehashed mechanics. At that part, might as well leave it out if you can imply in a different way "and then they had sex".

Having sex scenes in cinema does not make good cinema at all just because of it.

Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by LargoLasskhyfv on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:41PM (#28742445)
I'd mostly concur, but had to think of at least two movies which stuck, and weren't that scripted conforming to mainstream rules, no B-Movies either.

One would be The Limits of Control from 2009

[1] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1135092/

another I Origins from 2014

[2] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2884206/

I'm sure there are more, but can't remember right now, or don't care that much.

Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by graycat on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:46AM (#28737585)
Clarify your meaning of "reductionist"?
Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by Koshkin on Sunday October 03, 2021 @11:23AM (#28737875)
I think they mean “paying too much attention, and giving too much significance, to non-essential details.”
Re:Where Have All the Sex Scenes Gone? by graycat on Sunday October 03, 2021 @04:46PM (#28740378)
That sounds right.